Skip to main content

Request for Review and Proper Consultation – Proposed Safety Works, Brighton Rd / Fourth Ave, Sandgate

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 13
Closed: 7 Dec 2025
Principal petitioner: Cameron Ayre
ePetition number: 1537

The petition

Residents draw to the attention of - I write as a resident of Sandgate regarding the proposed safety improvement works on Brighton Road between Fourth and Fifth Avenues (the “Project”) Brighton Road safety improvements, Sandgate, Brisbane City Council. While I support the objective of improving pedestrian safety, I have serious concerns about the lack of genuine community consultation, the proposed traffic configuration, and potential breaches of Council’s legal and governance obligations. 1. Inadequate Community Consultation The consultation process to date appears inconsistent with both best practice and the Council’s own engagement policy: • The Project webpage indicated consultation was scheduled (e.g. “October 2025 – Project update & community engagement”), yet the notice, or invitation to participate wasn't received by all residents, and/or offered very little notice period to attend these information days, preventing meaningful participation. • A similar proposal in 2022 was withdrawn following strong community opposition submitted via a petition. At the time nearly 100 local community members put forward objections to these proposed works via a petition following a similar inadequate community consultation. These concerns were raised with the Honourable Lord Mayor, the local Councillor for the Deagon Ward and likewise with the Projects Team the Brisbane City Council. At that time the Council (or its representatives) indicated the works would not be proceeding. The re-emergence of the Project without renewed and genuine engagement raises concern about whether the earlier community voice has been given due weight. Under the City of Brisbane Act 2010 (Qld) and Local Government Act 2009 (Qld), Council must act in an accountable, transparent and sustainable manner. Its “Your City Your Say” framework commits to valuing resident input - particularly from those directly affected. This standard has not been met. I therefore request that Council pause further design or construction and undertake a fresh, transparent engagement process, including: • Direct notification (letter-drop) to affected residents; • A publicly advertised local information session; and • A clear feedback period before final decisions are made. 2. Concerns About Proposed Traffic and Amenity Changes While improving pedestrian safety is supported, the proposed left-in / left-out only configuration at Fourth Avenue is problematic. Key issues include: • Traffic diversion into Third and Fifth Avenues and Flinders Parade - increasing congestion and the risk for residents. The left-in/left-out change will divert traffic from using Fourth Avenue and Brighton Road access into alternative routes - most likely via Flinders Parade and Third, Fourth and Fifth Avenue. These roads are already heavily used, especially by local residents, which include young children, and elderly people. Increasing traffic volume along these streets will create additional risk and congestion, undermining the safety objective of the Project. • In addition, there are also concerns of further congestion along Brighton Road from motorists no longer being able to access the car park for ALDI, the Post Office, and Commonwealth Bank etc, by not being able to right into Fourth Avenue. This in turn would likely result in further congestion in and around the roundabout area near Woolworths, with increased traffic likely trying to access the car park at the traffic intersection at Third Avenue instead. • The removal of on-street parking spaces and the removal of several mature trees (even if replaced) is also a concern: the trees contribute to amenity, shade, and streetscape character. • Potential increase in confusion and travel time for visitors accessing nearby shops. Many local users - including those accessing the Aldi car park and other nearby shops, regularly use Fourth Avenue to access Brighton Road. The proposed change will require them to re-route, likely adding time, confusion, and traffic flow through quieter residential streets. While the current intersection does present pedestrian-safety challenges, the “fix” of left-in/left‐out is a fairly heavy-handed measures risk transferring, not resolving, safety concerns. Like the sentiment raised by a large section of the community via the petition in 2022, Alternative options should be properly assessed, such as: • Installing a signalised pedestrian crossing at Fourth Avenue / Brighton Road rather than a two-stage median refuge (like what has been done on Third Ave); • Retaining full turning access but improving sightlines, signage and pedestrian refuge; or • Removing the zebra crossing at Fourth Avenue in favour of existing nearby crossings (Third Avenue lights, Fifth Avenue zebra). There is also option of connecting a new zebra crossing along Keogh Street which may be a better alternative for traffic and still provide pedestrians with access to all the relevant shops safely. Council should release a traffic-impact assessment showing the modelling of diverted traffic and safety implications before works commence. 3. Legal and Governance Obligations Council’s current process appears inconsistent with its statutory and governance duties: • Lack of procedural fairness: Residents were not given genuine opportunity to participate. • Transparency and accountability: No statement of reasons or supporting documentation (traffic modelling, tree removal, safety studies) has been provided. • Potential for unreasonable decision-making: If the works increase risk or congestion in surrounding streets, the decision may be open to administrative challenge. Residents reserve the right to escalate the matter - including formal complaint to the Queensland Ombudsman, judicial review, or public campaign - should the Project proceed without rectifying these process and consultation issues. I refer to a previous petition on the same matter which closed on 19 March 2023 which received 94 signatures, and this petition has been submitted with less opportunity for engagement with the local community at this time.

Requested actions before proceeding further; we respectfully request that Council: a) Suspend all design and construction until proper consultation is completed b) Release all supporting documentation (traffic modelling, safety and amenity assessments, community feedback summaries) c) Reconsider alternative designs that maintain access and safety without displacing traffic. Conclusion - While I acknowledge the intent to enhance safety, the Project’s current form and process are deeply flawed. A transparent, inclusive approach is essential to ensure the outcome genuinely benefits both pedestrians and local residents.

Council response

The upgrade of the 2 zebra crossings on Brighton Road, between Fourth and Fifth Avenues, form part of Council’s Brighton Road Local Access Network Improvement program (the project), designed to deliver meaningful transport safety improvements across Brisbane.

Council has received numerous reports of crashes and near misses at these crossings, which were constructed to standards that have since been updated. As part of the project, these upgrades prioritise pedestrian safety and aim to address these risks.

Community engagement initially occurred in 2022 when feedback was sought on a proposed design. In March 2023, Council received a petition containing 93 signatures opposing the project. As outlined in Council’s response to this petition, the project was put on hold after it did not receive construction funding in Council’s Annual Plan and Budget 2023-24.

In late 2024, Council received a further petition containing 125 signatures requesting the project proceed. Funding was subsequently allocated in Council’s Annual Plan and Budget 2025-26 for further community engagement and construction.

In accordance with Council’s CED002 Community Engagement Policy , the local community was again engaged in late 2025 through:

Feedback from this engagement was overwhelmingly supportive of the project.

Regarding your concerns raised about the removal of the Fourth Avenue right turn, this change is required to address identified safety risks. Motorists continue to have multiple alternative routes to access Brighton Road.

Council is satisfied that all statutory requirements and governance obligations have been met in the planning and community engagement undertaken for the project. Construction is scheduled to commence in the coming months.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...