Skip to main content

Opposition of Pacific Golf Club's Non-compliant Driving Range

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 66
Closed: 13 Mar 2025
Principal petitioner: Patrick Goodison
ePetition number: 1380

The petition

As a member of the community I object to the “Other Change” application A006539920 by the Pacific Golf Club seeking approval to locate the illegally built 25m high structure closer to the residential area on the hill behind Stanmere and Almavale streets, Carindale than Council had approved. The application needs to be assessed by Council according to certain benchmarks of the Outdoor Sport and Recreation Code including: PO11 and PO12 which impose on the applicant an obligation to meet reasonable community expectations. PO11 states that the: Development ensures that the amenity of an adjoining residential zone is maintained and is consistent with reasonable community expectations for the use of a district park. The illegally constructed facility at almost 8 stories high, located on a prominent hill and approximately 20% closer to the residential boundary than approved, significantly impacts the visual amenity of the local community looking over the Carindale skyline and as such fails to ensure the amenity of the adjoining residential zone is maintained.The facilities of the Pacific Golf Club have never encroached on to the Carindale skyline.

My reasonable expectation is that any structure built would have been thoughtfully sited (not on a hill) and designed to reduce adverse impacts on the surrounding area as required by 9.3.15.2(2)(b) of the Outdoor Sport and Recreation Code and maintain the amenity of the adjoining residential zone, and be consistentwith community expectations built from 60 years of past operations by the golf club and not encroach on the skyline. My expectation is that such a facility would be no more than the maximum height of 9.5 metres (as specified as an acceptable outcome AO17 in Table 9.3.15.3—Outdoor Sport and Recreation Code) and be located like most district park facilities on low laying land where the visual amenity is least impacted. My expectation is that a driving range facility of this scale would be found in a non residential area or a significant distance away from one and normally in low laying areas and not immediately adjoining a residential area. As such the facility as, and where built does not meet the reasonable community expectations for the use of a district park.

PO12 states that the: Development ensures that: (b) the nature and type of amenity and crime prevention lighting used must be within the reasonable community expectations for a district park in the District zone precinct The Pacific Golf Course has operated without lighting for 60 years from its inception on the current site in 1964. My reasonable expectation is that it will continue to do so without lights or in accordance with its obligation under 9.3.15.2(2)(b) of the Outdoor Sport and Recreation Code it would site the facility not on a hill, but be sited so that it reduces adverse impacts on the surrounding area and preserve the amenity of the adjoining residential zone. PO12 states it must “ensure” it does this. Lighting in its current or even approved location will create a fully lit, 8 storey high, glowing cube on a prominent hill changing the Carindale skyline and negatively impacting the community. My expectation is that a driving range facility of this scale would be found in a non residential area or a significant distance away from one and normally in low laying areas and not immediately adjoining a residential area. As such lighting of the facility as, and where built is not within the reasonable community expectations. I object to this.

I ask the Pacific Golf Club to withdraw its Other Change application and act to meet reasonable community expectations which could include a driving range structure at the maximum height of 9.5 metres (as specified as an acceptable outcome AO17 in Table 9.3.15.3—Outdoor Sport and Recreation Code) with no lights in the approved location. I respectfully request this objection is passed on to the Council officer assessing this Other Change application A006539920, to assist them in determining the ‘reasonable community expectation’ as is required of them under PO11 and PO12 of the Outdoor Sport and Recreation Code.

Council response

Thank you for your petition requesting Council refuse the request to change a development application (other change) for a driving range at 420 Pine Mountain Road, Carindale (the site) (application reference A006539920). Council acknowledges your concerns raised in the petition, including impacts on the visual amenity of the site and the scale of lighting not meeting community expectations.

The site has an area of 138,100 square metres, is included in the Sport and recreation (District) zone within Council’s Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) and is not located within a neighbourhood plan. The site currently contains a mini golf course and driving range. Approval was given for an Extension to Outdoor Sport and Recreation (application reference A005918169), and a request to change the development approval under section 81 (minor change) of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act) for alterations to the mini golf course (application reference A006327335).

On 3 June 2024, Council received a request to change the development approval under section 82 (other change) of the Act and was properly made on 17 September 2024. The application is seeking approval to change the approved net height from 15 to 25 metres and includes the installation of lighting mounted on poles of various heights up to 25 metres. The applicant’s request to install lights throughout the site is to enable operations between the approved hours of 6am to 6pm. The application is currently being assessed by Council against the requirements of City Plan and in accordance with the provisions of the Act.

On 23 October 2024, Council issued an information request to the applicant which raised several matters, including lighting, visual impact, noise, location and maintenance of the net. On 12 February 2025, the applicant responded to Council’s information request. The response was assessed and an additional letter was issued on 19 March 2025 seeking further information about the lighting of the driving range, visual amenity and landscaping. Council has not yet received a response to this letter from the applicant.

The development application is subject to code assessment, and therefore does not require formal public notification and does not afford submitter appeal rights to the Queensland Planning and Environment Court, in line with the Act. However, Council will take all assessment matters into account, including the grounds of all submissions made during the assessment of the application, this includes any relevant petitions.

You can view a copy of the development application, including any additional information submitted, by visiting Council’s Development.i website at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au and by searching application reference number ‘A006539920’. You can also sign up for alerts to be notified of any updates to the application.

Thank you for raising this matter.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...