Skip to main content

Request to keep speed limit on Ashgrove Avenue

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 37
Closed: 31 Jan 2025
Principal petitioner: Paul Gerber
ePetition number: 1414

The petition

Residents wish to draw to the attention of Council another ePetition to review and reduce the speed limit on Ashgrove Avenue. While it is the Council's duty to periodically review speed limits, Ashgrove Avenue is a wide carriageway with ample shoulders and footpaths on both sides and the reduction of the speed limit is not supported by the empirical published crash statistics for Ashgrove Avenue and is considered punitive and arbitrary in nature. The reasoning for reduction in speed limits outlined in the other ePetition is based on anecdotal information.

Pedestrians and Bike riders: The crash data provided on the Queensland Government website for Ashgrove Avenue shows that in the 10 years of data from 2013 to 2023, there were only 2 accidents involving pedestrians and 5 involving bicycles. Both pedestrian accidents involve people emerging from behind parked cars, one in rainy conditions. For the bicycles, one was hit by a car turning at a give way sign, one by a car entering from a driveway and one hit a car door. The other 2 were hit on a straight road section in clear daylight, suggesting that speed was not a factor. None of these accidents were serious enough to involve hospitalisation suggesting slow speed. Accordingly, reducing the speed limit is unlikely to affect them.

Safety around schools and childcare centres: As discussed in the other ePetition, these are located at the ends of Ashgrove avenue where traffic is controlled with lights. The accidents recorded at these locations are rear enders and a bicycle hitting a car door. No further safety controls are considered necessary and reducing the speed limit along Ashgrove Avenue would not increase the safety at these areas. As discussed in the other ePetition, Ashgrove Avenue is an important link road between Newmarket and Waterworks Road. The claim that it features challenging corners and a narrow carriageway is anecdotal and the insinuation that Queensland drivers are unable to safely navigate the road at the current speed limit is not supported by the empirical crash data. Additionally, I have lived in the area for over 15 years and the majority of drivers drive at or below the speed limit. With regards to the few cars already speeding along the road, reducing the speed limit is unlikely to curb their behaviour.

Crash data: In the 10 years from 2013 to 2023, there were 34 accidents on Ashgrove Avenue. 5 of these occurred at Waterworks road and related to the traffic lights, 4 involve hitting a parked vehicle, 1 is leaving a driveway, and 4 are entering from a give way sign (and haven’t given way), 1 is a car doing a u-turn in front of another car, 5 cars rear ending the car in front and 1 car pulling out into a car on the road. Of the remaining 13, only 5 occurred on a curve and 3 of those are in the rain and leaving the road, suggesting not driving to the conditions. Again, reducing the speed limit is not likely to affect someone who is not going to drive to the road conditions, obey traffic signs or be unaware of their surroundings.

State-wide policies: Ashgrove Avenue doesn’t meet any criteria based speed limits, is adequately wide enough, not overly windy and is adequately utilised. Additionally, there are wide shoulders for car parking ensuring that the carriageway isn’t impinged and wide sidewalks and footpaths on both sides of the road allow for pedestrians. Accordingly, the current speed limit on Ashgrove Avenue meets the requirements of the QRSTUV: Guide to Speed Management.

In light of the above, we urge the Council when conducting a desktop review to determine that the current Ashgrove Avenue speed limit is appropriate and request that the speed limit on Ashgrove Avenue is not arbitrarily reduced.

Your petitioners therefore request that the speed limit on Ashgrove Avenue remains at 60KPH.

Council response

Your request for Council to maintain the speed limit of Ashgrove Avenue is noted. All speed limits across Queensland are determined in accordance with guidelines set out in the Queensland Government’s Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) and the Queensland Road Safety Technical User Volumes , ensuring that speed limits throughout Queensland are set in a consistent and credible manner.

Under the provisions of the MUTCD, 60 km/h speed limits are generally appropriate for suburban roads in urban environments, such as Ashgrove Avenue.

Roads identified as potentially suitable for reviewed speed limits are then subject to a formalised speed limit review process, which takes into account the road’s function, recorded traffic speeds and volumes, environmental characteristics and crash data.

A review of Queensland Government crash data from the previous 5 years has not identified significant crash history, which indicates motorists are safely able to navigate this road. An assessment has also been carried out and did not identify notable changes to the road network or land use in the area that would impact on traffic speeds. Taking into consideration the intended function of Ashgrove Avenue and that the adjacent land use has not changed, Council considers the 60 km/h speed limit in place to be appropriate at this time.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...