Skip to main content

Major concerns about Lota House development

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 7
Closed: 20 Oct 2024
Principal petitioner: Nadia Di Martino
ePetition number: 1373

The petition

Last year we noticed that about 70 trees along the fenceline in the reserve had crosses marked on them, presumably for felling. The Council was duly informed. Having had a look at the map, it has suddenly clicked with me what they plan to do. The developers are obviously intent on pushing the boundary 7 metres eastward and in the process clearing a significant amount of vegetation. The effect on the local environment will be catastrophic for the following reasons:

Erosion concerns - in 2022, during the last floods the cliffs experienced a landslip that closed the Esplanade, near Royal Queensland Yacht Squadron, and the Council spent months rectifying it at great cost to ratepayers. The cliffs are obviously prone to erosion and lack proper soil stability. Clearing the ridge line of trees has the real potential of further damage to the cliffs. In addition to this, I have just been up to the site and it looks like the developers have shown a blatant disregard to erosion and sediment procedures.

Environmental concerns - soil and silt eroding from the cliffs will inevitably end up in Moreton Bay. The number one environmental challenge for the Bay at the moment is silt being deposited on seagrass beds and consequently it is having a disastrous effect on marine wildlife such as dugongs and turtles. Recent coverage on the ABC has highlighted this problem which pointed out that a major source of silt in the Bay is from large development sites. Further to my concerns for the ecology of the Bay is the effect that the expansion of this development will have on terrestrial wildlife. This site provides a significant wildlife corridor between the northern parts of the Wynnum/Manly/Lota area and is also potential habitat for our locally endangered koala population.

Concerns regarding visual amenity - the Lota House Development will already have a significant deleterious effect on the visual of Lota and Manly. Expanding the development beyond the existing boundary and the subsequent tree clearing will have a dramatic and negative effect on the visual amenity of the area.

Developers MUST stop destroying this beautiful part of the world!

Council response

Thank you for your petition objecting to the Lota House development at 162 Oceana Terrace, Lota (application reference A006311610).

The site has a total area of 39,969 square metres and is located within the Community facilities (Health care purposes) zone and Wynnum-Manly neighbourhood plan as part of Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan). The site is the Edwin Marsden Tooth Memorial Home (also known as Lota House) and is a Queensland State Heritage Place. Lota House is operated by Anglicare Southern Queensland and includes aged care facilities, independent living units and a dementia care unit.

The sites’ recent development application history shows a development application for a Retirement facility was approved by the Queensland Planning and Environment Court on 13 December 2019 (application reference A004942635). A subsequent request to change the development approval under section 81 (minor change) of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act) was approved by Council on 31 May 2023 (application reference A006165073).

On 6 July 2023, Council received the other change application (reference A006311610) to change the development approval under section 82 of the Act and was properly made on 2 August 2023. The development application was approved on 20 February 2024, after being assessed by Council against the requirements of City Plan, and in accordance with the provisions of the Act. The proposed changes were focused on increasing the total independent living units from 100 to 187 via 2 new buildings, increased on site-car parking, revising outdoor and indoor communal facilities, and consequential additional vegetation proposed for removal and replacement on site.

The other change application was code assessable which did not require formal public notification. However, Council’s delegate took all assessment matters into account, including the grounds of all submissions made during the assessment of the application, this includes any relevant petitions.

In addressing the assessment benchmarks of City Plan, the applicant submitted revised architectural plans, a town planning report, landscape concept plan, arboriculture report, traffic impact assessment, waste management plan, engineering services assessment, stormwater management plan, heritage report, vegetation clearing and fauna management plan and a visual impact assessment.

The other change application required referral to the Queensland Government’s State Assessment and Referral Agency which issued conditions on the development approval to Council on 31 October 2023. These conditions related to erosion and sediment control, construction management, tree protection zones for retained vegetation, environmental offsets, and landscaping on site including compensatory planting and post development arboriculture impact assessment. The approved documents, as well as conditions issued, formed part of Council’s decision in determining compliance with assessment benchmarks of the City Plan.

While it is acknowledged the development footprint will require the removal and replacement of some vegetation no approval has been given for works beyond the existing boundaries of the site, including existing vegetation within the Esplanade and its ridgeline or within the unformed part of Grace Street. It has been determined the development will not result in unacceptable impacts on local amenity.

A copy of the development approval, including any additional information submitted, can be located online via Council’s Development.i website at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au and by searching application reference number ‘A006311610’.

Thank you for raising your concerns.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...