Skip to main content

Development proposed for 51 Bramston Terrace Herston Development Application AO06248821

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 107
Closed: 12 Sept 2023
Principal petitioner: Marit Hegge
ePetition number: 1247

The petition

Residents draw to the attention of Lord Mayor the major concerns of residents about the proposed development at 51 Bramston Terrace, Herston AO06248821. We contest that it does not meet community expectations. Of note, these concerns include:

• Excessive height and site cover dominating surrounds and diminishing amenity

Context : The developer is seeking major relaxation on code requirements. While coded for five (5) stories they are seeking seven (7) plus a rooftop pool floor. Additionally, the developer is seeking a major relaxation on the site coverage requirements on a massive 2,000sqm block on top of one of the highest hills in the area.

Impact: The development will dominate the local area, dwarfing nearby properties including heritage buildings and character homes. The amenity of a the local area will be negatively impacted while the developer will benefit solely though marketing properties with some of the best views across the city.

• Inadequate consultation leading to less community engagement and response.

Context: Many of the diagrams and graphics provided by the developer are deemed blatantly misleading acting to downplay the height and scale of the build. While an amended plan was provided an update to all diagrams and graphics relating to height and size was not. The developer did not hold any public consultation except by posting signage on the site.

Impact: Members of the community were confused about the scale of the project, some initially supporting the development without realising the full impact. While it is understood that under BCC consultation guidelines the developer does not need to meet with the community, a failure of Unison Property to undertake this, left community members trying to decipher what were deemed confusing and misleading technical documents limiting capacity of the community to object or clearly articulate concerns. The process has worked to diminish the voice of those most affected.

• Community response manipulated by developer’s affiliates/associates

Context: Near identical submissions of support were lodged en masse by the developer’s property sector associates who did not have any obvious connections to the local community. One of these responses was from the developer's own management team.

Impact: It is understood that the developer needs to demonstrate it has met community expectations and has attempted to do this by trying to skew community engagement responses in their favour. This has left the local community feeling disrespected and concerned about whether the developer is completely indifferent to those who areed impact the most.

• The parking and traffic analysis is sub-par and demonstrates little understanding of local issues.

Context: The area around the development is significantly congested. The analysis fails to take into key issues including the impact on key nearby intersections at Herston Road and Butterfield Street. It contains no references to predicted increases in traffic and street parking which flow from Herston Quarter and Victoria Park developments (e.g. increased traffic from the new parking station which will exit into Bramston Terrace and increased weekend traffic and parking congestion at large events at the park). The 104-bedroom complex has only six visitor car parks.

Impact: Major increase in parking congestion in an already saturated area. Traffic issues on local and main roads in the area.

Your petitioners therefore request that Brisbane City Council:

A) ensures that this building is not more than five (5) stories and the site cover is not increased beyond code requirements;

B) updates and provides documentation with clearer representations of the bulk and size of the build compared to adjoining buildings;

C) makes sure the developer revisits and updates its poor traffic and planning studies;

D) revisits its policies and procedures for the community consultations on impact assessible development to drive transparent and meaningful engagement. This should include the development of mechanisms to mitigate risk of manipulation by the property sector as well as requirements for meeting and communicating directly with those impacted.

Council response

Thank you for your petition requesting Council address concerns about the development at 51 Bramston Terrace, Herston (the site) (application reference A006248821).

Council notes your concerns with the development application in relation to excessive building height and site cover, inadequate public consultation and community engagement, and insufficient car parking and traffic analysis. Additionally, Council notes the concerns you have raised regarding the impact on the amenity of the site, including the overshadowing of nearby heritage buildings and character homes.

Council also notes your requests for Council to reduce the building height to five storeys and to ensure that the site cover is compliant with the acceptable outcome in Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan), and for the applicant to submit revised documentation including traffic and planning studies.

The development application for the site was lodged on 8 April 2023, and was properly made on 27 April 2023, for a Material change of use for the purpose of a Multiple dwelling for 38 units. The applicant submitted a town planning assessment report, architectural plans, landscape concept plans, engineering infrastructure report, traffic engineering report, waste management plan and arboriculture impact assessment as part of this application. Council’s Development Assessment team, which includes town planners, engineers, architects and landscape architects, considered the material submitted to be technically sound and adequately demonstrated compliance with City Plan assessment benchmarks, including performance outcomes and in accordance with the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act).Council took all assessment matters into account, including the issues raised by submitters at the time of decision, and concluded that the application was in accordance with the requirements of City Plan. Council approved the application on 6 September 2023, which was prior to the receipt of this petition.

All current development applications are available on Council’s website and local residents can register for alerts when new development applications are lodged. This enables the local community to be informed about applications and to ensure their feedback is received before a decision is made, in accordance with the time periods driven by the Queensland Government Department of State Development, Infrastructure, Local Government and Planning’s Development Assessment Rules (the Rules).

Submissions concerning this development, which were properly made during the formal public notification period between 27 June 2023 and 18 July 2023, in accordance with the Act, have the legal right to appeal Council’s decisions through the Queensland Planning and Environment Court.

You can view a copy of Council’s decision, including conditions of the approval and Notice About Decision, which provides a detailed response to all matters raised in submissions. This documentation is available by visiting Council’s Development.i website at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au and searching development application reference A006248821.

Council also notes your request to review community consultation policies and procedures with respect to impact assessable development. Public notification requirements for impact assessable development applications are determined by the Act and the Rules.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...