Skip to main content

Residents Request Brisbane City Council (BCC) Develop and Provide a Plan and Work With Residents to Move the Flying-Foxes On

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 142
Closed: 31 July 2023
Principal petitioner: Millie Takai
ePetition number: 1242

The petition

Permanent flying-fox camps have swollen beyond capacity in suburbia and are causing serious mental and physical health problems to residents. This includes but is not limited to:

1. Constant, offensive smell that is sickening, and prevents normal household activities e.g. Cannot keep windows open, cannot use outdoor areas.

2. Disruptive shrieking noises before dawn every morning without relent that disturbs sleep causing sleep deprivation.

3. Daily deposits of highly corrosive bat excrement that destroys outdoor items and areas if not removed immediately; including decks, pools, outdoor furniture, roof, solar panels, cars, pathways, washing, etc.

4. Increased financial and time burden for residents for maintenance and cleansing of flying-fox excrement.

5. No escape from all of these challenges as this is our home. We live with this 24/7.

6. No support from Brisbane City Council (BCC) to mitigate all of the above-mentioned challenges with the massive flying-fox infestation.

Your petitioners therefore request Brisbane City Council (BCC) amend its policy regarding flying-fox management. We request that BCC follow the precedence set by other Queensland Councils, such as Fraser Coast Regional Council (FCRC), and considers Commonwealth obligations, but does not allow this to override the State or Local Government law or policy. We request that BCC follow Queensland State Government guidelines, whereby local governments have an as-of right authority under the Nature Conservation Act 1992 (NCA) to manage flying-fox roosts in Urban Flying-Fox Management Areas (UFFMA) within each local government area. This will allow the use of deterrents to prevent a roosting area from being established and damaging/destroying private property, public park land, playgrounds, and other amenities. Where permanent flying-fox camps are causing serious grievances to residents as previously outlined, we request that flying-foxes be moved on to mitigate community suffering, and reduce the mental and physical health problems to residents and businesses. We request that BCC involves the community in achieving this outcome.

Council response

Thank you for your petition requesting Council develop a plan, while working with residents, to permanently move flying-foxes on and that Council does not allow Commonwealth legislation to limit actions otherwise available under Queensland Government legislation.

Three species of flying-foxes are found in Brisbane, with more than 30 permanent flying-fox camps located on Council land adjoining residential areas, waterways, public space and/or sporting fields.

The grey-headed flying-fox ( Pteropus poliocephalus ), which is listed as vulnerable nationally, is also protected by the Commonwealth Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (the Act). The Act makes Queensland’s Nature Conservation Act 1992 , including subordinate legislation and guidelines, obsolete where grey-headed flying-foxes are present. The protection afforded to wildlife through the Act also extends to the protection of their feed and roost trees.

Flying-foxes are native to Brisbane and all native wildlife is protected by the Nature Conservation Act 1992 . While the Nature Conservation Act 1992 does allow Council an as‑of‑right authority to manage these animals, any management must be done so in strict accordance with the Flying-fox Roost Management Guidelines and the Code of Practice – Low impact activities affecting flying-fox roosts . These as-of-right management activities are limited to non‑lethal methods and ensures acceptable welfare outcomes for flying-foxes. To support this outcome, Council has developed its own Statement of Management Intent for flying-foxes in Brisbane that describes the actions that will be considered in managing a flying-fox roost.

In Brisbane, dispersal or relocation of flying-foxes is not included as an option, as all roosts are located in urban areas. The process of dispersal typically involves the use of strobe lights, loud noises and the use of smoke machines, all of which are deployed during the early hours of the morning when animals are attempting to return to their roost, usually between 3-6am. These activities need to be undertaken for several hours each morning before daylight, for an undetermined period of time, usually over a number of weeks or months. As you may appreciate, this can be extremely distressing for residents and domestic animals.

When dispersal activities have been deployed in other localities, the flying-foxes only move a short distance from the roost. Additionally, when undertaken in urban areas, dispersal has the potential to move animals to less suitable locations, where they have an equal or greater community impact such as on private properties, schools or street trees. In almost every case where dispersal has been used in other parts of Australia, once dispersal activities cease, flying-foxes return to the area they were moved from unless complete habitat removal is undertaken. Due to this evidence, dispersal is not used in Brisbane.

Council will continue to monitor flying-fox numbers as well as surveying their camps for cleanliness, undertaking cleansing activities if Council infrastructure becomes soiled. Council is also investigating what vegetation management works can be undertaken to establish a clearer buffer between riparian vegetation and nearby private properties.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...