Enough is Enough- No more flooding in Brighton from undersized 1946 Drainage
The petition
Since 1946 the Brighton catchment has been developed from bushland to now 244 ha of developed land without upgrading the stormwater flow capacity under Flinders Bridge and Beaconsfield Bridge. After major flooding in 2015 and 2022, residents opposed Maclean Street development with community action including: 1. 710 signatures opposing the development 2. Over 50 development lodgements with concerns about flooding 3. An engineer's report outlining that the outdated drainage raises flood levels by 2.1m in a 1 in 100 year flood. flooding 810 properties 4. Over 120 community emails outlining the urgent need to upgrade drainage before development can proceed.
However, BCC responded to community concerns by asking a developer to model the difference in flood to 200 ha upstream of Beaconsfield Bridge. This fundamentally placates and dodges our concerns that there’s insufficient capacity for drainage for development to proceed.
We ask the Council to complete the task of code assessment and actually answer our questions:
Q1. Is there sufficient capacity in the Beaconsfield and Flinders Bridges to handle the post development flow rate Of 38.5m3/s (refer to the developer's report)?
Q2. Will the water from the development go down the drain directly to the ocean through the drain or will the water go into other properties?
We insist on a stop of Maclean Street development until this code assessment is complete for compliance with section 7 of BCC City Plan (stormwater). Given federal and state governments have offered to pay 50% of upgrade costs, this is an urgent call to action for Council to upgrade Flinders and Beaconsfield Bridges to comply with City Plan prior to the upcoming third La Niña event. We requested this on April 10 2022.
The ratepayers of Brighton catchment will no longer be ignored. Enough is enough.
Council response
Thank you for your petition raising concerns about the assessment of the development application for the reconfiguration of a lot at 32 Maclean Street and 121 and 131A Speight Street, Brighton (A005967268), and requesting for responses to flooding and stormwater drainage.
The application was approved by Council on 7 October 2022, after being assessed by Council’s Development Services, City Planning and Sustainability, in accordance with the requirements of the Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) and the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act). Council’s delegate took all assessment matters into account, and concluded the application was in accordance with the requirements of City Plan.
From the time the application was lodged, Council has been aware of the significant community interest in the development. The application was code assessable and, therefore, formal public notification was not required under the provisions of the Act. Notwithstanding this, Council received numerous submissions and enquiries from the community during the course of the application. All issues raised by submitters were taken into consideration during the assessment.
The issue of flood immunity for future houses, as well as the potential impacts on surrounding properties, was an important part of Council’s assessment. Council employs specialist hydraulics engineers to review development applications and scrutinise reports and information provided by developers. There are cases where the Council engineers conclude developments would result in unacceptable impacts and these applications are not supported. However, this was not the case for this development in Brighton.
The applicant submitted a response to the stormwater, earthworks and flooding elements of the Stormwater code of City Plan that was certified by a Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland. In accordance with Council’s assessment practices, the applicant’s response was assessed by Council engineers, who agreed with the findings. The application assessment factored in building pads and earthworks for future houses. The assessment found the proposed development to be acceptable as the development stormwater represents a minor percentage of the catchment (0.03% of the total flooding) and the impacts would be insignificant. The development will not worsen flooding or stormwater on adjoining properties. Under City Plan, if there is no measurable or direct impact from that development, Council cannot refuse the application or expect a developer to fix an existing capacity issue in the locality.
The prioritisation of future bridge upgrades for construction is determined by considering the frequency of flooding, severity of damage and available budget, as determined through Council’s annual budget process. However, Council recognises the severe consequences of recent wet weather events and prioritises flood mitigation works throughout the city. In particular, the highest priority is given to construction works in areas where residential properties are flooded and where safety concerns arise due to flooding of roads or intersections.
An investigation has been commissioned by Council to update the existing flood study for the Brighton area. Once the study is complete, possible additional flood mitigation measures in the affected areas will be determined. Any identified works resulting from the investigation will be evaluated for funding alongside other potential projects across the city, according to citywide priority and budget availability, as determined through Council’s annual budget process.
Having carefully considered the flooding and tidal movement in the area, Council has made the decision to install a micro height gauge downstream of Beaconsfield Terrace. This gauge will enable Council to gather information following rainfall events, thereby improving the understanding of tides and rainfall events at this location.
The applicant has received development approval and they are now lawfully able to carry out stormwater drainage, traffic functional layout, signs and line markings and roadworks, as well as subsequent Operational Works permits. There is no mechanism for these approvals to be revoked and where there is no breach of approvals, Council has no grounds to issue stop work or enforcement notices.
Brisbane is built on a floodplain, which means we will never be able to prevent flooding. As such, our city needs to move comfortably with and manage the risk of flooding, ensuring flooding is expected, designed and planned for.
You can view a copy of the development approval online at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au by entering application reference number ‘A005967268’.
Thank you for raising this matter.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...