Stop the BCC City Projects Office proposed changes to the intersection of Brighton Rd at Fourth & Fifth Ave, Sandgate QLD
The petition
To the Lord Mayor & Councillor Cassidy, I am writing to you on behalf of many of the residents of the Deagon Ward community, in relation to the Brisbane City Council’s City Projects Office letter sent on the 25th October 2022 regarding suggested changes to the corner of Brighton Rd at Fourth and Fifth Avenue, Sandgate. In their letter, the City Projects Office detailed a proposed 2 week consultation period relating to several traffic changes including but not limited to the following:
As part of the works, Council also propose to remove three established trees to enable the changes to be implemented. The reason behind these proposed changes is to improve the safety for both motorists and pedestrians at these intersections. Although the reasons behind wanting to improve safety at these intersections is valid, the process the City Projects Office has followed regarding both community engagement, and likewise the proposed changes are flawed and will only cause further traffic and safety issues to occur in the local area.
The Concerns with the City Projects Office Proposed Changes
Prior to using this portal, we started a separate online petition via change.org which collected more than 130 signatures in a short space of time from people within the community angered by the process the City Projects team has undertaken on these proposed works. Aside from the obvious of many of the local’s not wanting any of the trees along Brighton Rd to be cut down, there have also been numerous complaints both via the petition, and likewise on several Facebook community group pages detailing the shortcomings of this process.
The Concerns with the Brisbane City Council's Process
There have been numerous concerns raised by the local residents in the way the City Projects Office have handled the proposed local access network improvements. Some of the feedback includes the consultation period not being long enough; the submission process using only email responses being flawed, given this isn’t supportive of some of the residents in the area that aren’t comfortable using this platform; there being no further engagement with the community (e.g. a meeting set at the local town hall to discuss the proposal); and not enough communication from Council on the changes in the first place. There have also been a number of people who have complained about never receiving the initial or follow up letter from Council, and therefore it also appears that the letter may not have gone out to all of those in the Deagon Ward in the first place, which is yet another shortcoming. Whilst an issue that might only affect a few streets/roads may only require a notice to be sent to only a handful of residents, given the commercial nature of this location it would appear logical for the letter to go out to all residents within the ward, in addition to other forms of communication such as proposed signage advising residents of the proposed works. In addition to the above, Council’s communication throughout this process has been lacking. Despite numerous emails and phone calls being made to Council's project management team in charge of this project, so far the City Projects Office has remained silent in their response to our objections, leading to further frustration. This silence has been following Council’s letter advising local residents of their decision to proceed with the works on the 24th of January 2023, but without any further communication as to why this decision was made. Aside from the lack of communication, it is also evident many of the locals are unhappy with the overall lack of engagement in the lead up to these proposed changes, given there was no meeting organised with the local community to discuss the issue and the possible solutions. Most of the concern from the community thus far is the fear that if these planned changes go ahead, the motorists who use Fourth Ave to access the undercover car park to ALDI, Chemist Warehouse etc, will be forced to use other means to access Keogh St or Brighton Rd when heading towards Brighton. This will potentially include turning right onto Fourth Avenue from the car park, left onto Flinders Pde and left onto Fifth Ave to access Brighton Rd. Or alternatively turning left onto Brighton Rd, and using the roundabout near Woolworths to circle back. Both options will cause traffic choking points to occur near the corner of Brighton Rd and Keogh St, and similarly to the entrance and exit of the roundabout, which is already congested at certain times of the day. In addition to the above, the proposed changes would likely turn a residential street into a traffic thoroughfare. As a resident who has two young kids living on what is an already busy street, this is not something we want to see happen. Especially with so many young kids living in the area, and playing on the weekends. There are likewise a number of local residents who use Keogh St to cut through the back of Sandgate/Deagon, instead of going through the main part of Sandgate via Rainbow St. By using this route, we are able to avoid additional traffic congestion near the intersection to Sandgate train station. However the proposed left hand only turn, would create more traffic to flow through the roundabout and into Rainbow street causing further congestion to occur at this busy intersection which isn't ideal. Whilst there is the option for motorists to use the exit onto Third Ave, which has a traffic light on the intersection with Brighton Rd, this exit traditionally isn’t used as frequently given the main bulk of the car parks are located in the undercover section abutting Fourth Ave. There are also concerns of the build-up of traffic from motorists needing to use this intersection if the planned works go ahead.
Suggested Alternatives
The main issue with this intersection at present is that worlds appear to be colliding between traffic and pedestrians using the zebra crossing near Fourth Ave. To address this, there are several alternatives that could be considered by council in this matter.
Option 1 - Council consider installing a set of traffic lights and a pedestrian crossing, similar to what has been done on Third Ave to give motorists the right of way to turn right under controlled conditions. This potentially could be done on the basis that drivers can take a left hand turn at any time on a cautionary basis, so traffic is allowed to flow in this direction like they do elsewhere. If a traffic light were installed, it would mitigate the need for zebra crossing at this intersection.
Option 2 - Council consider shifting the pedestrian crossing further along Brighton Rd, so that is in not so close to the corner of Brighton Rd and Fourth Ave. In doing so, this would enable motorists and pedestrians to have more time to see and react when coming in and out of Fourth Ave to access shops and the waterfront. Some residents have indicated there is a good spot opposite the bus stop that would be more suitable to allow pedestrian and motorists more visibility.
Your petitioners therefore request Council put a halt to these works until such time as further engagement is undertaken with the local community. Whilst changes are likely needed, they shouldn’t be in lieu of having to cut down mature trees and creating other congestion and safety risks elsewhere. At the very least we would recommend a Town Hall meeting being scheduled so that residents can share their concerns and thoughts before any works go ahead, given many of the locals I have spoken with are opposed to the current proposal.
Council response
Council's Local Access Network Improvements suburban works program (the program) delivers transport infrastructure improvements across Brisbane. Works typically include new and upgraded active transport crossing facilities and minor intersection upgrades that enhance access and safety for all road users.
Brighton Road between Fourth and Fifth Avenues, was identified as a location where pedestrian access and safety improvements would be beneficial. Council engages with residents and businesses who may be affected by works to understand the experiences and expectations of residents and businesses through different levels of engagement, guided by Council's Community Engagement Policy .
Community feedback is an important part of the program and is considered alongside our technical inputs to confirm the implementation of proposed treatments.
On 25 October 2022, Council distributed a letter to residents, businesses and property owners on Brighton Road between Fourth and Sixth Avenues, and Fourth Avenue between Brighton Road and Flinders Parade, to seek feedback about proposed improvements which included:
- Upgrading the existing crossing on Brighton Road at Fifth Avenue to a raised zebra crossing, to moderate vehicle speeds and enhance pedestrian crossing safety.
- Replacing the existing zebra crossing on Brighton Road at Fourth Avenue to a two staged zebra crossing to enhance pedestrian crossing safety and improve the visibility of pedestrians.
- Removing a section of the central median island near Fourth Avenue to extend the space for pedestrians waiting to cross.
- Extending the length of the existing central median island on Brighton Road at Fourth Avenue and restricting right turns from Fourth Avenue to Brighton Road to reduce the risk of crashes between turning vehicles and the pedestrian crossing on Brighton Road.
- Installing no stopping parking restrictions on the eastern side of Brighton Road at the pedestrian crossings to improve visibility between road users and pedestrians.
- upgrading kerb ramps, footpath connections to current standards and new pavement, street lighting and turfing.
The consultation period was open for two weeks from 25 October to 8 November 2022. This provided residents, businesses, and property owners with an opportunity to provide feedback through multiple avenues of communication, including email, calling the project hotline, or sending a letter by post.
Your request for Council to consider alternative options for Brighton Road near Fourth Avenue is noted. The proposed improvements are considered appropriate to address the immediate safety concerns for pedestrians, reducing conflict points between pedestrians and motorists, while enhancing visibility for all road users on Brighton Road near Fourth Avenue. However, Council appreciates your requests for the project team to conduct further community engagement before progressing to the next stages of the project. Consultation with the community is important to ensure Council delivers balanced solutions and meets the needs of the community and our growing transport network.
As this project did not receive funding for the 2023-24 financial year, the project will not progress at this time. Should the project secure funding at a future date, Council supports your requests for further community engagement to be undertaken prior to progressing to the next stages.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...