Skip to main content

No roads in Brighton wetlands

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 1,280
Closed: 13 Mar 2023
Principal petitioner: Tina Salt
ePetition number: 1207

The petition

Community group '4017 Unites' is against Council’s decision to let a developer build a road in the waterway corridor of Brighton Wetlands, the area that takes water away from our homes during a rain event. This is also the area where homes nearby, and downstream of this site, flooded in February last year.

The waterway corridor helps capture, store and move water. It also provides important linkages between habitat areas for native wildlife. Under the Natural Assets Local Law 2003 , all vegetation in a waterway corridor is protected. However, a developer can simply apply for a permit and Council will waive the law without any public notification, community consultation or appeal process (thanks to Brisbane City Plan 2014 ).

To outline the issues:

In a time when leaders are spruiking about resilience funding for houses in flood prone areas, it seems hypocritical then to permit development in critical catchments that naturally flood and are there to take water way from homes.

We urgently need your signature so we can obtain a moratorium (suspension of activity) on the development and protection of the Wetlands.

4017 Unites appeals to Lord Mayor Adrian Schrinner to place a moratorium on operational works imminently occurring at 32 Maclean St & 121 Speight St in Brighton and inside the waterway corridor of Brighton Wetlands so that a number of issues identified in the Development Application A005967268 can be resolved. Council can begin the process of un-gazetting State road reserves and conservation zoning so the wetlands are better protected.

Council response

It is noted you have identified several concerns with the proposed development including:

The application was approved by Council on 7 October 2022 after being assessed by Council’s Development Services (DS), City Planning and Sustainability, in accordance with the requirements of Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) and the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act). Council’s delegate took all assessment matters into account, and concluded the application was in accordance with the requirements of City Plan.

From the time the application was lodged, Council has been aware of the significant community interest in the development. The application was code assessable and, therefore, formal public notification was not required under the provisions of the Act. Notwithstanding this, Council received numerous submissions and enquiries from the community during the course of the application. All issues raised by submitters were taken into consideration during the assessment. However, ultimately the development complies with the planning intent for the Low density residential zone by providing freehold residential lots of an appropriate size.

Six of the proposed lots will be accessed via Maclean Street, utilising an existing gazetted, but unformed road, extending Maclean Street. The area of land that will comprise the road extension is not Council‑owned land and is not part of the Brighton Wetlands. This area of land is designated road reserve and is owned by the Queensland Government. While the extension of the road will result in a change to Maclean Street, Council cannot prevent road reserve being used for road purposes. Given the area of road extension is not part of the Brighton Wetlands, this development does not set a precedent for development in Brighton Wetlands.

As part of the submissions received during the assessment of the application, many residents asked why Speight Street could not be used to service all proposed lots, which would negate the need for the extension of Maclean Street. Speight Street is unable to be used to service all proposed lots due to the irregular alignment of the site access handle to Speight Street. Access via this handle currently has severely limited capacity for vehicle movements in general, and for the collection of refuse from the proposed new lots (particularly those fronting Maclean Street). It would not be considered safe or efficient for a refuse collection vehicle to service the 18 mobile bins (for the proposed 9 lots) from the existing access handle from Speight Street.

To facilitate the forming of the existing gazetted road for the Maclean Street extension, it was determined the removal of a number of trees is required to conform with the necessary standards of road design to provide safe and efficient pedestrian and vehicle access and collection of refuse. The Maclean Street extension will be generally consistent with the grades and crossfalls of the existing Maclean Street, although the road extension will have a reduced width due to its function providing access to only six lots. The road infrastructure elements, including the carriageway, verge crossfall (to drain to the pavement and not back to the lots), access driveways to lots, provision of bin collection points and multiple service alignments directly through the root zones of the existing street trees, would be incompatible with the retention of the trees. Incidentally, removal of the trees may assist in managing bushfire risk at this residential location.

During the application, the applicant submitted an ecological report to evaluate the impacts of the proposed development. The vegetation removal as part of this proposal would have a minimal impact on fauna. The development approval provides new street tree planting on the Maclean Street frontage of the subject site, which is consistent with City Plan requirements that apply to all subdivisions across Brisbane.

The applicant has obtained the required permits for the removal of vegetation under the Natural Assets Local Law 2003 (NALL). NALL permits do not require public notification.

The inclusion of sites in the Flood overlay or the Waterway corridors overlay of the City Plan do not mean development is not able to occur, although there are cases where development would result in unacceptable impacts. The applicant submitted a response to the stormwater, earthworks and flooding elements of the Stormwater code that was certified by a Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland. This assessment found the proposed development to be acceptable, with no material stormwater impacts on surrounding properties. The application assessment factored in building pads and earthworks for future houses. In accordance with Council assessment practices, the applicant’s response was assessed by Council’s own engineers, who agreed with the findings.

Brisbane is built on a floodplain, which means we will never be able to prevent flooding. As such, our city needs to move comfortably with and manage the risk of flooding, ensuring flooding is expected, designed and planned for. Council officers are well aware of the extent and impacts of the 2022 flood event, and other historical events, and the assessment of this application took into account that knowledge.

The applicant has received development approval and they are now lawfully able to carry out stormwater drainage, traffic functional layout, signs and line markings and roadworks, as well as subsequent Operational Works permits. Approvals for tree removal have also been obtained. There is no mechanism for approval to be revoked and where there is no breach of approvals, Council has no grounds to issue stop work or enforcement notices.

Petitioners can view a copy of the development approval online at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au by entering application reference number ‘A005967268’.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...