Protect low-cost housing and historic buildings, reject the redevelopment of 210 Gladstone Road, Dutton Park
The petition
We object to Development Application A006082835 for a large indoor childcare centre at 210 Gladstone Road, Dutton Park on the basis that it is contrary to the public interest. This proposed development: - does not comply with numerous aspects of City Plan 2014 - will remove existing residential units, displacing low-income Dutton Park residents and lead to a reduction in the supply of affordable housing in the local area - is significantly taller and bulkier than envisaged in the neighbourhood plan - will generate excessive traffic volumes on Deighton Road, a narrow residential side-street - undermines the historic value of the commercial building at the corner of Deighton Road and Gladstone Road (which is supposed to be protected by the Commercial Character Building Overlay), and destroys the residential cottage fronting Gladstone Road which was built in or before 1917 and is still in reasonably good condition - does not set aside enough space for deep-planted trees or green space.
We are also particularly concerned that the style of childcare centre proposed does not have enough space for the large number of intended enrolments (95 children) and does not include any outdoor, natural spaces for the children to play in. We do not think it is desirable for young children to be stuck indoors all day with minimal fresh air and no meaningful connection with the natural world. By lodging an application that makes no serious attempt to comply with the City Plan or the Neighbourhood Plan, the developer is wasting council resources and the time and energy of local residents.
We respectfully urge Brisbane City Council to reject this development application and preserve the existing uses of the site for small businesses and low-cost housing.
Council response
Council notes the concerns you have raised with the development application for a Material Change of Use for the purposes of a childcare centre and for Building Work for the demolition of two commercial character buildings on site. You have outlined that the proposal does not comply with numerous aspects of Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) and that the proposed removal of existing residential units will displace low-income Dutton Park residents and reduce the supply of affordable housing. In addition, it is noted you are concerned the proposal is significantly taller and bulkier than envisaged in the Dutton Park-Fairfield neighbourhood plan and will generate excessive traffic volumes on Deighton Road, Dutton Park.
Council also notes your particular concern that the development will undermine the historic value of the commercial character building at the site, which is protected by the Commercial character building overlay. Furthermore, Council notes your concern that the proposal does not set aside enough space for deep planted trees or greenspace and the proposed childcare centre does not include sufficient outdoor space for children to play.
On 17 August 2022, a development application was received seeking approval for Material Change of Use for the purposes of a Childcare centre, and for Building Work for the demolition of two commercial character buildings on site.
The proposed development involves the full demolition of the timber cottage fronting Gladstone Road and the post–1946 dwelling fronting Deighton Road. The historical commercial character building located at the corner of the site will be retained with internal renovations proposed to facilitate a new commercial fit out. The existing Food and drink outlet on ground floor will be retained, and new Offices and a Health Care Service is proposed on the first floor. The side staircase is proposed to be demolished.
The remainder of the site is proposed to be developed into a childcare centre with a basement carpark. The proposed childcare centre will have a maximum capacity of 95 placements, be four storeys (with a maximum height of 16.75 metres) and include an open rooftop playground.
The development application is subject to impact assessment and therefore public notification is required in accordance with the Planning Act 2016 (the Act). Council sent an Information Request to the applicant on 14 September 2022, and the application remains within the Information Request response period. Council outlined matters in the Information Request including the proposed demolition works, scale of the development, impacts from the proposed childcare centre and impacts on refuse, stormwater and traffic. While Council has received three public submissions to date, the formal public notification will commence once the applicant has responded to the Information Request in accordance with the Act. Submissions received during the public notification period will be afforded appeal rights, in accordance with the Act. The matters raised by all submitters will be carefully considered by Council officers as part of the assessment process.
You can track the progress of this application, including any additional information submitted, online on Council’s Development.i website at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au by entering application reference number ‘A006082835’. You can also sign up for alerts to be notified when the applicant responds to the Information Request or when formal public notification commences.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...