Skip to main content

Proposed Clearing of Wetlands for Development Subdivision

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 714
Closed: 31 Aug 2022
Principal petitioner: Marni Linnell
ePetition number: 1135

The petition

An application for development of adjoining properties at 32 Maclean Street and 121 Speight Street, Brighton proposes to clear protected Wetlands (including the removal of four established, mature eucalyptus trees) and the extension of Maclean Street into these Wetlands to provide access for three of the proposed houses (nine in total).

Points for consideration: 1. The reclamation of these protected Wetlands contravenes the Sandgate Neighbourhood Plan, which specifically mentions the retention and protection of established Wetlands. 2. What environmental impact study (if any) has been conducted to ascertain the impact on wildlife who currently reside in these wetlands? 3. These Wetlands are low-lying areas, prone to flooding. This area regularly floods during heavy rains and was completely submerged during the recent flooding (waist height). 4. What purpose does the bushcare levy play, when Wetlands can be cleared? 5. Many residents have lived in this area for generations. It is noted that one of the justifications for removing these trees are safety issues. These trees do not pose direct risk to ANY property. This is an erroneous justification which has no basis in truth. 6. Phone calls made to Council in January to enquire as to the planned development resulted in advice from Council that no new roads would be created and that any and all access to these properties would be via the existing easement on 121 Speight Street. 7. Given the major infrastructure required, why is Council funding these major costs for the commercial interests of this developer? 8. All residents feel aggrieved by these development plans and upset that they have not been given an opportunity to be apprised of the proposal and be able to provide submissions.

That the proposed reclamation of the Brighton Wetlands is not approved and that the development is reconfigured for new homes on this site to have access via the existing easement on 121 Speight Street.

Council response

It is noted you have identified several concerns with the proposed development including a proposal to clear protected wetlands and the removal of four mature eucalyptus trees that do not pose any direct risk to property.

You state that Council provided advice that no new roads would be created and any access to the proposed lots would be via the existing easement on 121 Speight Street. However, the proposal includes the extension of Maclean Street into the wetlands to provide access for three of the proposed lots which contravenes the Sandgate district neighbourhood plan, which specifically mentions the retention and protection of established wetlands. Additionally, the wetlands are low-lying areas and prone to flooding. The area regularly floods during heavy rain and was completely submerged during the recent February 2022 flood.

Furthermore, you seek information on the purpose of the Bushland Preservation Levy when wetlands can be cleared, as well as information on whether an environmental impact study has been conducted to ascertain the impact on wildlife. It is noted you also believe that the reclamation of Brighton Wetlands contravenes the neighbourhood plan, the development would have access via the existing easement at 121 Speight Street, and that Council is supporting the commercial interests of the developer.

The application was approved by Council on 7 October 2022 after being assessed by Council’s Development Services team in accordance with the requirements of Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act). The application was Code assessable and therefore formal public notification was not required under the provisions of the Act. However, all issues raised by submitters were taken into consideration during the assessment. Your concerns were also taken into account as part of the assessment, having been received prior to the decision being made.

The subject site is in the Low density residential zone of City Plan, and located in the Sandgate district neighbourhood plan, but not in a specific precinct. The subject site is recognised as being unusually large for this area and, therefore, is able to be subdivided in way that results in similar lot sizes to those already established in the area.

Your concerns about the Bushland Preservation Levy and conservation of wetlands are acknowledged. Council has purchased and protected over 8.3 hectares of land in Brighton through the Bushland Acquisition program and Council is continuing to use Bushland Preservation Levy funds to purchase and protect natural habitat.

The land of the proposed road extension of Maclean Street immediately adjoins the Brighton Wetlands but is not part of the wetlands. The proposed extension is within the Queensland Government owned road verge; therefore Council is unable to refuse the application. The developer will be required to fund any infrastructure required to serve the development, including the extension of Maclean Street within the designated road.

The designated road is not subject to any City Plan ecological overlays, and therefore the removal of trees to facilitate the road extension were supported. The applicant submitted an ecological report on 1 September 2022 to evaluate the impacts of the proposed development. The vegetation removal as part of this proposal would have a minimal impact on fauna. The development approval provides new street tree planting on the Maclean Street frontage of the subject site, which is consistent with City Plan requirements that apply to all subdivisions across Brisbane.

Council acknowledges the significant flooding that has occurred in Brighton. The application was assessed against City Plan policies regarding ensuring flood mitigation and impacts. The application demonstrates the development will not cause significant change in stormwater flows and flooding to downslope areas.

Petitioners can view a copy of the development approval online at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au by entering application reference number ‘A005967268’.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...