Reject unsustainable private development of Shafston House and preserve green space for public use
The petition
Development application A005933994 for highrise apartments of 15+ storeys on the Shafston House site (23 Castlebar Street, Kangaroo Point) will cause a wide range of negative impacts including (but not limited to): - loss of open green space - loss of space for large trees - reducing opportunities for pedestrian and cycling connections through to a future public riverwalk - additional car traffic on surrounding streets - loss of view corridors and air flow - excessive overshadowing on neighbouring buildings - undermining the heritage value of this historic site - high carbon emissions and excessive consumption of non-renewable resources due to unsustainable building designs - disruption of stormwater flow paths and possible increased flooding risks - exacerbating the housing affordability crisis through further gentrification
Residents are particularly concerned that the LNP-dominated council's City Plan treats this as a Code Assessable development, denying locals legal pathways to challenge this project.
Residents call on Brisbane City Council and Lord Mayor Adrian Schrinner to reject this development application outright. Residents also call for the heritage-listed riverfront lawn in front of Shafston House to be acquired by BCC and preserved as public parkland with 24-hour public access.
Council response
Thank you for your petition requesting Council reject the proposed development on the Shafston House site, located at 23 Castlebar Street, Kangaroo Point (the site) and preserve greenspace for public use (application reference A005933994). Council notes your request to reject the application outright as you believe the proposed development will have negative impacts and is unsustainable. Council notes your request that the site is acquired for 24 hour public parkland use.
Council notes your concerns include the following.
Tree retention, building design and building separation to allow for natural air flow and ventilation, reduced energy consumption, and minimal overshadowing and traffic generation are all relevant matters taken into consideration as part of the assessment of the development application. Stormwater management and ensuring appropriate consideration of flooding risks will also be considered, as well as maintaining significant views of the heritage buildings.
In relation to the provisions for a riverwalk connection, Council’s Long-Term Infrastructure Plan (LTIP) confirms the intention to facilitate the future construction of a continuous riverwalk along the river frontage of the site, connecting Mowbray Park to Holman Street, Kangaroo Point. The LTIP specifies the width required for the future riverwalk pathway is 4.5 metres measured from the mean high water springs line of the Brisbane River. The proposed development does not prejudice a future riverwalk connection.
On 28 January 2022, a development application was lodged for a multiple dwelling, landscape works, filling and excavation and preliminary approval for existing buildings to be used as a multiple dwelling over land at 23 Castlebar Street, Kangaroo Point (A005933994). Council’s assessment began on 7 February when the application was properly made.
In February 2005, the site was entered within the Queensland Heritage Register under the Queensland Heritage Act 1992 (QHR:600241). The Queensland Heritage Register includes Shafston House and its detached kitchen (constructed in 1851 and extended later), a ward block (1919), orderlies’ accommodation (1928) and postal depot (1936). The heritage overlay is also applied over the site under City Plan. The proposal is therefore subject to the heritage protections and regulations that apply to Queensland and local heritage places. Responsibility for managing the heritage values of Queensland heritage places rests solely with the Queensland Government’s Department of Environment and Science.
In accordance with Schedule 10, Part 8, Division 2, Subdivision 3, Table 2 of the Planning Regulation 2017 (the Regulation), the application was referred to the State Assessment and Referral Agency (SARA) for the assessment of the impact of the proposed development on the site’s heritage significance.
SARA has responded to the referred application with an Advice Notice dated 21 March 2022 in which the applicant is advised that the development application has not adequately demonstrated compliance with the State Development Assessment Provisions. This notice outlines key issues and actions required to be addressed before any decision can be made. Once SARA finalise their assessment and advise Council of their decision, under the Planning Act 2016 (the Act) and the Regulation, Council is obliged to act on this decision.
Assessment of the development has also included an assessment by the Independent Design Advisory Panel (IDAP) on 10 March 2022. Issues raised by IDAP have been incorporated within Council’s information request dated 21 March 2022.
The development application is currently within the information request response period and this period has been stopped by the applicant until 17 October 2022. The applicant’s response to Council’s information request is now due prior to 24 October 2022 unless further extended by the applicant. A response to the SARA Advice Notice was also extended at the request of the applicant and is now due on 20 October 2022, unless further extended by agreement between SARA and the applicant.
In addressing the assessment benchmarks in City Plan, the application included technical reports addressing traffic and noise impacts, landscaping and a heritage impact assessment.
Council is obligated by Queensland Government legislation to assess all applications in full on their merits against the relevant assessment benchmarks in City Plan and in accordance with the Act. Therefore, Council has no legislative means of prohibiting development, stopping the lodgement of a development application, or refusing the application prior to the conclusion of the assessment process.
The development application is subject to code assessment and therefore public notification and submitter appeal rights are not required in accordance with the Act. City Plan defines which developments trigger code or impact assessment through zoning, neighbourhood plans, and overlays and this policy is publicly notified, amended in response to public submissions, and reviewed through two Queensland Government state interest reviews before it is set.
To date, a total of 83 submissions have been received objecting to the proposed development. The matters raised by all submitters will be carefully considered by Council officers as part of the assessment process.
You can continue to track the progress of this application, including all documents relating to the Information Request and SARA Advice Notice on Council’s Development.i website at https://developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au by searching the development application reference number ‘A005933994’.
Thank you for raising this matter.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...