Skip to main content

Protect the character of Wooloowin Avenue

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 40
Closed: 20 Nov 2021
Principal petitioner: Elliott Franks
ePetition number: 1103

The petition

Residents draw to the attention of the Lord Mayor to the recently approved Development Application at 44 Wooloowin Avenue Wooloowin. The approval of an extension to the side of the house and a large carport on the front and side boundary are not keeping with the Traditional Character Housing guide for Brisbane. The approval showcases that the Brisbane Town Plan and associated development assessments do not reflect the intention of the guide. According to the Brisbane City Council Traditional Housing: Alterations and Extensions Design Guide this proposal for a new extension of office/gym and ensuite built in under veranda: - Does not respect the local context and streetscape by creating a dominant modern feature that detracts from the original house and surrounding houses does not celebrate the front steps- in this case the front bridge, which is also present at the neighbouring property 46 Wooloowin Avenue. Doesn’t respect the original building by removing walls and other elements which were built before 1911 Does not respect the surrounding area of significant, well respected character houses. The extension is not sympathetic to the original house a. Siting the extension as dominant feature to the front boundary 0m front and side 0m b. Scale detracts from the original house and dominates the existing house c. Extension to the side is not set back from the main building line, so views of the house are obstructed and the existing verandahs does not remain prominent.

Your petitioners therefore request Council overturn the decision to approve this application.

Council response

Council notes your concerns include the following. - The approval of an extension to the side of the house and a large carport on the front and side boundaries are not keeping with Council’s Traditional Housing: Alterations and Extensions Design Guide (Traditional Housing Guide) for Brisbane. - The approval showcases that the Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) and associated development assessments do not reflect the intention of the Traditional Housing Guide. - The Traditional Housing Guide requires that the extension must respect the local context and streetscape by not creating a dominant modern feature that detracts from the original house and surrounding houses and celebrates the front steps. - The extension to the front of the house has a scale that detracts from the original house and dominates the existing house. - The extension to the side of the house is not set back from the main building line, therefore, views of the house are obstructed, and the existing verandah does not remain prominent.

The subject site is located in the Low-medium density residential (2 or 3 storey mix) zone under City Plan and is subject to the Clayfield-Wooloowin district neighbourhood plan. The subject site is within a Traditional building character overlay (TBC) - Neighbourhood character sub category.

The subject site is comprised of two lots (Lot 191 and Lot 192 on RP19392) with a combined area of approximately 810 square metres. The built form in the local area predominantly consists of single detached dwellings and multiple dwellings with a range of heights from one to three storeys.

Council received the development application for an extension to a house on land subject to a TBC on 3 October 2021. The proposed development application was approved by Council on 3 November 2021 after being assessed against the requirements of City Plan and in accordance with the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act).

The development application was subject to code assessment and therefore public notification was not required in accordance with the Act. Notwithstanding this, a total of nine submissions were received during the assessment of the proposed development application. It is noted that submissions received for code assessable applications do not afford the submitter the ability to appeal Council’s decision in the Planning and Environment Court. The matters raised by all submitters were carefully considered by Council officers as part of the assessment process.

Brisbane’s Future Blueprint, released in 2018, was developed as the result of more than 100,000 interactions with residents of Brisbane as part of Plan your Brisbane. Brisbane’s Future Blueprint included a principle to ‘Ensure best practice design that complements the character of Brisbane’. In an effort to ensure Council could identify best practice, Council further engaged with residents and industry stakeholders to develop a guide for alterations and extensions to traditional houses.

The intent of the Traditional Housing Guide is to guide people seeking to alter and extend their house in a design that is sympathetic to the character of the house and respectful of the streetscape setting in which they sit. The guide showcases high-quality design outcomes and strategies for extensions and alterations to traditional character houses. However, it is a guide only and does not form part of the assessment benchmarks for this type of development.

While the Traditional Housing Guide is not legally binding in considering current applications, it does serve to support Council’s policy direction with regards to character housing and will inform possible future amendments to City Plan. Council officers are currently considering a range of possible amendments to City Plan to support better outcomes for character houses. These possible changes will further ensure the character of traditional houses is retained whilst striking a balance to allow for adaptation over time.

In considering this development application, Council was bound to assess the development against the relevant assessment benchmarks as identified in City Plan at the time it was lodged and follow the planning processes outlined in the Act and the Planning Regulation 2017 .

Council has an obligation to assess a development application on its merits while keeping in mind the need to provide for the intended built form, amenity and living environments as envisioned by City Plan. Additionally, City Plan is required by the Queensland Government’s planning legislation to be performance based. As such, the legislation requires City Plan to be flexible and take into account the variety of specific factors that affect a particular site. It allows the applicant to either comply with the acceptable outcomes or put forward alternative solutions to address the performance outcomes (POs) for their proposal.

Council supported a PO for the front setback of an office/gym as it will not be visible from the street frontage and does not dominate the existing house when viewed from the street. This is due to that component being no higher than street level. While the carport sits above the office/gym structure, that component was not part of Council’s assessment.

The carport design and dimensions met the prescribed accepted provisions within City Plan. As such, it was not subject to assessment within the approved development application. It is noted that while Council’s Traditional Housing Guide informs the provision of City Plan, it is not itself an assessable document. Although the carport and setback to the side boundary were not assessable aspects within the development application, a building approval under the Queensland Development Code, including assessment against setbacks, is still to be completed by a private building certifier via a siting variation application.

A siting variation application request was submitted to Council on 8 December 2021 (application reference A005899876). As part of the assessment process, neighbours can provide comments to the assessing officer. This application has not yet been decided as Council has requested changes to be made to the design of the carport wall.

Details of the development application, including all documents relating to the approvals, can be accessed on Council’s Development.i website at https://developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au, by searching on the development application reference number ‘A005850607’.

Thank you for raising this matter.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...