Skip to main content

Truck ban and lower speed limit Desgrand Street Archerfield

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 6
Closed: 11 Aug 2021
Principal petitioner: Steven Eichmann
ePetition number: 1053

The petition

Residents draw to the attention of Council to the non-local traffic including delivery vehicles and heavy vehicles using Desgrand street as a shortcut between Kerry and Boundary roads. Most drivers do not obey the 50 km/h speed limit and hit the speed bumps and cause excessive noise, this is problematic particularly at night.

Your petitioners therefore request Council lower the speed limit to 40 km/h and ban vehicles exceeding 4.5 tonne from using Desgrand street. The local traffic only signage at the Kerry Road end was previously damaged by large vehicles and then removed when the power pole was changed, this needs to be reinstated as well. There is currently no speed signage on Desgrand street.

Council response

Thank you for your petition requesting Council ban heavy vehicles, lower the speed limit to 40 km/h and install speed limit signs on Desgrand Street, Archerfield.

Your request for Council to lower the speed limit from 50 km/h to 40 km/h has been noted. Council evaluates requests for 40 km/h speed limits based on the guidelines outlined within the Queensland Government’s Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD). Roads identified as potentially suitable for the review of speed limits are then subject to a formalised speed limit review (SLR) process, which considers the road’s function, recorded traffic speeds and volumes, environmental characteristics and crash data. Where the review supports a change to the posted speed, the proposal is then presented to the Speed Management Committee (SMC) for endorsement, which has representatives from the Queensland Police Service (QPS), the Queensland Government’s Department of Transport and Main Roads (TMR) and Council. If the endorsed speed limit differs from the existing speed limit, Council will arrange for amendments to existing signage.

As per the MUTCD, 40 km/h speed limits can be installed when specific conditions are met. Typically, 40km/h speed limits are installed in areas of very highly concentrated pedestrian activity, for example, at schools or where traffic calming devices have been installed as part of a local area traffic management scheme. Within Brisbane, 40km/h speed limits are common in CBD streets, where there are high levels of pedestrian activity generated by business activity

As Desgrand Street has traffic calming devices and data from a traffic survey undertaken in March 2020 indicates 85% of all motorists travel at or below 44 km/h in the northbound direction, and 40 km/h in the southbound direction, it is considered there is enough evidence to indicate that Desgrand Street may meet the requirements for a reduced speed limit. As such, a formal SLR will be undertaken with the recommendation submitted to SMC for endorsement.

While traffic calming has its benefits, it may not completely address all poor driver behaviours. Poor behaviours, such as speeding and hooning, are often best addressed through enforcement of the Road Rules. The petitioners are therefore encouraged to raise any concerns with speeding motorists, or motorists driving in a dangerous manner, directly with the QPS via the Hoon Hotline on 13 HOON (13 46 66).

Your request for Council to ban heavy vehicles exceeding 4.5 tonnes from using Desgrand Street has been noted. TMR has developed guidelines and policies to promote the safe and efficient movement of large vehicles throughout Queensland. The guidelines state that vehicles with an overall length not exceeding 19 metres and have a gross vehicle mass not exceeding 42.5 tonnes are provided with general access to all roads in Queensland.

The movement of trucks is not generally restricted in residential areas because delivery and service vehicles often have destinations within these areas, which requires them to travel along residential streets. This may include refuse collection vehicles, local delivery trucks, and construction vehicles. As such, truck bans should only be used in cases where the road or structures such as bridges would be at risk of damage due to continued use by heavy vehicles. Therefore, the use of truck bans on streets where these are not required for safety reasons can jeopardise their effectiveness, and result in reduced compliance on roads where they are genuinely needed for safety reasons. For these reasons, a truck ban on Desgrand Street is not recommended.

It is expected that there will be some truck use on Desgrand Street, for example, to facilitate refuse collection and local deliveries. However, a review of the most recent traffic survey conducted on Desgrand Street in March 2020 shows the average weekday two-way traffic as 857 vehicles per day, with 18.2% being heavy vehicles. This equates to an average of 155 heavy vehicles per day using Desgrand Street. The volume of heavy vehicles using this street is considered higher than what could typically be expected on most local residential streets.

Desgrand Street is located close to land used for industrial purposes however, it is noted there is no direct access to any of these properties from Desgrand Street and intersecting local residential streets do not provide through access. Access to industrial properties in the local area is preferred via the Major Road network and designated Freight Accesses, such as via either Kerry Road, Beaudesert Road, Boundary Road or Beatty Road.

Taking into consideration the heavy vehicle data from the March 2020 traffic survey, Council appreciates there are likely a number of non-local heavy vehicles using Desgrand Street to travel Boundary Road and Kerry Road. While traffic calming devices have been installed to discourage non-local traffic use, Council acknowledges the March 2022 traffic survey indicates that non-local motorists are still using Desgrand Street to avoid traffic congestion and delays on Beaudesert Road. Specifically, delays turning right from Boundary Road into Beaudesert Road, and turning left from Beaudesert Road into Boundary Road. Beaudesert Road in Archerfield is under the jurisdiction of TMR. As such, any improvement to Beaudesert Road and its intersections with Kerry Road and Boundary Road to reduce traffic congestion and delays is outside of Council’s jurisdiction. Accordingly, your concerns with non-local traffic use on Desgrand Street has been referred to TMR for their consideration and direct reply.

Your request for ‘Local Traffic Only’ signage to be reinstated has been noted. Council’s Public Space Operations, City Standards, Brisbane Infrastructure, reinstated the sign on 4 November 2021.

Thank you for raising this matter.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...