Skip to main content

Proposed development at 447 Gregory Terrace, Spring Hill

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 335
Closed: 11 Apr 2021
Principal petitioner: Melissa Botha
ePetition number: 1016

The petition

Residents draw to the attention of Brisbane City Council the development applications for 447 Gregory Terrace, Spring Hill (Development Application Number: A005608964). The application seeks to a demolish the adjacent Energex building (A005679852) and erect a 15-story residential complex in its place, as well as a 15-story hotel, in the parking lot, currently separating The Brisbane Lady Gowrie Child Centre and a 6-story high apartment complex (Avalon Parkside).

Petitioners believe that the current development application is not in accordance with the local surrounds and does not acknowledge the historical and cultural significance of Spring Hill. This is Brisbane’s oldest suburb and renowned for its character housing and structures. The current development application is out of step with Spring Hill and we respectfully seek Council’s assistance with ensuring it remains the unique and appealing place it currently is. We the undersigned are concerned with the proposal, in particular: 1. The health and safety consequence of eliminating natural light to neighbouring residents, including a childcare centre and elderly residents; 2. The health and safety consequence of restricted ventilation to neighbouring residents and increased noise and air pollution; 3. The traffic concerns resulting from increased vehicle traffic as well as traffic congestion in and around major access routes to RBWH; 4. Fire safety concerns due to the restricted access and minimal distance between structures; 5. The impact to amenity and privacy on nearby residents due to the proximity of the proposed towers, in particular the hotel proposed for the narrow parking lot; 6. The height and size of the structures that would directly overlook neighbouring properties and their inconsistency with the local surrounds, including two (2) heritage buildings (Carrington and Grange Hill) in the immediate vicinity.

Your petitioners therefore request that, in accordance with Council’s long-term community plan for the city, in particular, Council’s commitment to ‘our well-designed, subtropical city’ Council acknowledge the importance of preserving Spring Hill and reject the development application A005608964 due to the abovementioned concerns raised by petitioners and local residents.

Council response

Council notes the following concerns you have raised in the petition.

The site is located within the Mixed use (inner city) zone under Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) and the Spring Hill east precinct within the Spring Hill neighbourhood plan.

On 4 December 2020, a development application was lodged over the site for a Material change of use for Multiple dwelling, Short-term accommodation, Function facility and Food and drink outlet. The application was properly made on 11 December 2020. The application involves the redevelopment of the site for a mixed-use development, comprising two towers with a maximum height of 15 storeys.

The proposed development comprises of 113 Multiple dwelling units and 120 Short-term accommodation units, together with ancillary facilities, a Function facility (323 square metres gross floor area (GFA)), Food and drink outlet (360 square metres GFA) and communal (indoor and outdoor) spaces associated with both the Short-term accommodation and Multiple dwelling. Vehicular access will be gained from Gregory Terrace for the Short-term accommodation use and Warry Street for the Multiple dwelling use and servicing areas.

On 23 April 2021, the proposed development was approved by Council after being assessed against the requirements of the City Plan and in accordance with the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act). The proposed development was subject to Code assessment and therefore was not required to undertake public notification.

The proposed development was approved, subject to conditions which included requirements for screening treatments to windows and balconies to minimise opportunities for overlooking and impacts to adjoining residents. The applicant provided additional information through the assessment process demonstrating that the buildings have been designed to minimise impacts on the privacy and amenity of adjoining residents with balconies and open space areas orientated away from adjoining open space wherever possible. Relevant conditions have been imposed for car parking, access, stormwater, construction management and to minimise any potential noise impacts. Hours of operation for the non-residential uses have been limited to between 6am and 10pm.

In terms of setbacks, the setback from Building B (Hotel), and the boundary adjoining Avalon Parkside apartments ranges from a minimum of four metres, to a maximum of five metres. Additionally, the setback from the Hotel to the southern boundary adjoining the childcare centre ranges from a minimum of 4 metres, to a maximum of 4.725 metres. Council has conditioned screening on the windows to prevent overlooking to adjoining sites. Fixed screening has been provided on the northern side of the Hotel to minimise any privacy and amenity impacts on adjoining neighbours.

The development application was referred to the Department of State Development, Infrastructure, Local Government and Planning’ State Assessment and Referral Agency (SARA) as a concurrence agency on 18 December 2020, as the site adjoins a State Heritage place. SARA issued a response on 23 February 2021, stating that under section 56(1)(b)(i) of the Act the concurrence agency conditions must be attached to any development approval relating to the development application. SARA supported the development application, subject to conditions.

The City Plan sets site cover provisions which seek to balance the extent of built form and open space on a site and manage bulk and scale. In this location, the neighbourhood plan outlines that the maximum site cover is 60% of the site area. The proposed development application proposes a site cover of 56.6%, complying with the acceptable outcome in the City Plan. Overall, the built form, bulk and scale of the proposed development is considered to align with the expectations for future development in the Mixed use (inner city) zone and Spring Hill east precinct of the neighbourhood plan.

In regard to the impact on traffic movements and congestion, Council’s assessment team, which includes traffic engineering specialists, reviewed the proposed development in detail and concluded that overall, the Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland endorsed Traffic Report by Bitzios Consulting had satisfactorily demonstrated compliance with the relevant performance outcomes of the Transport, access, parking and servicing code and planning scheme policy in the City Plan. It is noted that Gregory Terrace is a Suburban (Major) Road and the new vehicle trips anticipated to be generated by the proposed development are fewer than one per minute in peak hours and as such, it is anticipated that the proposed development will not have a significant impact on the operation of the external road network.

To view all documents relating to this decision, the petitioners can visit Council’s Development.i website at developmenti.brisbane.qld.gov.au and search for application reference number A005608964.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...