Petition to consider objections to Elizabeth Street bicycle lane
The petition
Residents draw to the attention of Cr Murphy, Brisbane City Council and The Public & Active Transport Committee
Starting the week of December 1st, 2020, Brisbane City Council commenced removal of right lane loading zones, disabled parking and related roadside amenities along Elizabeth Street, Brisbane City, for conversion into a bicycle lane. It is understood Council reached out to members of the cycling community in planning this development but no business consultation was undertaken. As a direct consequence, works have already caused a myriad of disruptions and negative long term effects are inevitable without open and considered dialogue. Although it’s understood the bicycle lane is to be a 12 month trial, the lack of transparency thus far raises significant concerns that affected parties will continue to be shut out of the conversation. It is important to note that the purpose of this petition is not to halt progress on increased bicycle access throughout the City of Brisbane, or even on this particular project. Rather, it is to work with all relevant parties toward solutions that will meet the needs of businesses, service providers and cyclists alike. It is also to seek assurances from Council that consultation will be actively sought with all affected parties on both the project in question and on similar projects in future—not just with parties who would very obviously be in favour.
TRAFFIC CONCERNS
Increased congestion during peak hours due to loss of clearway.
PARKING CONCERNS
The relocation and reduction of loading zones servicing businesses along this stretch of road is directly causing service delays and disruptions, particularly affecting Australia Post and other delivery services. Disabled parking has been relocated, making it difficult for people with disabilities accessing this retail and dining precinct. Paid street parking has been lost, removing convenient access to a significant number of small businesses. Reduced access for food delivery service operators, increasingly relied upon by local cafes and restaurants for revenue, has resulted in cases of local businesses having their own access blocked. This is to say nothing of the knock on effect felt by customers. Loss of Council ticket revenue. Business Concerns With no advance notice of the project provided to local businesses or service providers, these parties were deprived of any opportunity to raise concerns related to normal operation of their businesses. These concerns are largely related to customer foot traffic and the resulting income losses and this latest development adds insult to injury following many years of construction and restricted pedestrian access along Elizabeth Street. Restaurants and small businesses who’ve already suffered sharp downturns in profits during 2020’s COVID-19 pandemic were finally starting to see a return of foot traffic to the area, only to see that disrupted once again during the peak Christmas shopping season.
Although we recognise that finding a perfect solution to these concerns may not be easy, we would like to propose the following for discussion:
Our hope is that business impact will be as much a consideration as community benefit.
Council response
Your petition has been investigated and it was considered by Council at its meeting held on 11 May 2021. The CityLink Cycleway is a joint initiative of Brisbane City Council and the Queensland Government. The project is jointly funded through Council's Active Transport Infrastructure Fund (ATIF) and the Queensland Government Works for Queensland grants program. The trial includes a new, separated two-way cycleway in the Central Business District (CBD) along Elizabeth Street, Edward Street, and William Street to Melbourne Street via the Victoria Bridge. The cycleway occupies a kerbside traffic lane and separates cyclists from vehicle movements using raised yellow kerbing. Council is conducting the trial for a 12-month period and invites the community to have to have their say now that the cycleways on Elizabeth Street and Edward Street are operational.
Council is seeking feedback from a range of users, including residents, businesses, cyclists and community members for inclusion in Council's evaluation of the trial. We welcome feedback on all aspects of the project including safety, cycleway usage, alternative alignments, design improvements, parking and loading zone changes, and benefits of using the cycleway. To have your say on the trial, please complete the online survey or provide your feedback to the project team by visiting Council's website and searching `CityLink Cycleway'.
In relation to your request to reinstate loading zones and parking for businesses during trading hours in the bike lane on Elizabeth Street, this has not been included in the scope for the trial as the objective of the trial is to provide a dedicated, separated cycleway in the CBD that improves safety for all road users and encourages the use of active and sustainable modes of transport in Brisbane.
To improve safety for both bike riders and drivers in the CBD, the trial includes raised yellow kerbing to physically separate vehicle and bike movements. The physical separators are in place along the length of the cycleway, with gaps at driveways and key locations for garbage collection, which means that vehicles would not be able to enter or exit loading zones. The kerbing is also required to meet the Queensland Government's Department of Transport and Main Road's design guidelines to allow e-scooters to use the cycleway. Council is not currently proposing to remove the physical separators and is unable to reinstate loading zones on the affected sides of Elizabeth Street and Edward Street during off-peak periods.
However, after receiving feedback from business operators on Elizabeth Street, Council has now installed an additional loading zone on the northern side of Elizabeth Street between George Street and Albert Street. This new passenger and commercial loading zone replaced the previous night time taxi zone located outside the Myer Centre, which Council installed in December 2020. Due to the significant constraints on Elizabeth Street, including high bus volumes, the new loading zone operates daily between 11:30pm and 5:00am.
Council understands that traffic volumes in the CBD have generally increased in recent months with more people returning to work and choosing to drive private vehicles due to COVID-19. These recent increases in traffic volumes, in conjunction with other major construction projects across the CBD and South Brisbane, has seen congestion increase across key locations in Brisbane, including the CBD. To help balance this, Council is delivering on its strategic vision for the CBD with improved public and active transport connections, including the trial and Brisbane Metro project, to help reduce the need for car-based travel into or through the CBD.
Council considered that consultation during a 12-month trial period is appropriate for this project. Throughout the trial period, Council is committed to keeping the community informed, listening and acknowledging concerns that may arise, and providing feedback on how public input was considered as part of the overall trial evaluation.
In relation to your request for transparency about how the trial is deemed a success, Council will take into consideration community feedback and other factors, including congestion and safety, to evaluate the trial. Council will publish a community engagement summary as part of the full trial evaluation, which will be made publicly available.
Thank you for raising this matter.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...