Defer off-leash trials until significant dog issues have been addressed
The petition
Residents draw to the attention of Council that the dog off-leash trials on Brisbane beaches and foreshores need to be deferred until the significant dog issues that deeply divide the community have been addressed. While the majority of dog owners are doing the right thing, there are those who underestimate the control they have over their dogs and what dogs can do. And then there are dog owners who simply don't care about anybody else but themselves, not only making it uncomfortable for others but also endangering people and wildlife.
This is not a new issue. There have been previous (failed) attempts to open up part of the 4017 foreshore to off-leash dogs in the past. Following a proposal put forward by the Sharing Shorelines Working Group to allow the area from Twelfth Avenue to the Brighton Park (the entire foreshore of Brighton) in December 2014 to be reserved as an off-leash area for dogs, a local community group lodged a Brisbane City Council e-petition that ended on 30 June 2015. "This petition is important because we believe that local people and vulnerable migratory shorebirds should be able to enjoy the use of the Brighton Foreshore without dealing with off-leash dogs. We want to keep the Brighton foreshore area safe for people to enjoy as the main priority for the area."
The community group consisted of people that were not represented in the Sharing Shorelines Working Group such as: 1. Parents of small children who do not want them to be approached by off-leash dogs. 2. Owners of dogs who choose to walk their dogs on a leash who do not want them to be approached by off-leash dogs. 3. Seniors who walk along the waterfront and sand flats who do not want to be approached by off-leash dogs. 4. Other recreational users of the waterfront (including kite surfers) who do not want to be approached by off-leash dogs. 5. Environment groups who are concerned with our commitments to the International Ramsar Convention. 6. Local residents who want to keep the foreshore available to local families rather than to become Brisbane’s destination for people from outlying areas, including Moreton Bay Regional Council, who bring their dogs.
Following this petition the proposal forwarded by the Sharing Shorelines Working Group was rejected in 2015. Unfortunately, since then nothing at all has changed. Far too frequently the Sandgate foreshore and other foreshores look more like off-leash areas with little control exercised by Brisbane City Council and Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service. On 19 April 2019, a toddler was attacked by two dingos on Fraser Island. This incident created headlines and the question of culling of dingoes was widely discussed, once again.
According to documents downloaded from the Brisbane City Council website, in the period between 1 October 2017 and 30 September 2018 at least 468 dog attacks on people and at least 669 dog attacks on an animal were reported. Almost none of those attacks seem to have made headlines and no actions to remedy this significant issue have been discussed. The Courier Mail reported on 17 January 2019 that an average of 38 animal attacks per week were reported to the Brisbane City Council last year. Former Lord Mayor Graham Quirk reported: “An alarming number of reports of aggressive dog behaviour and dog attacks have also been received by Council, with more than 1,800 complaints last year."
On Jan 17, 2019 it was reported in the Courier Mail that changes are being made to off-leash dog areas on Bribie Island following a spike in attacks on wildlife. With the proposed trial to allow dogs on Citycats, Council in effect declares all dogs to be potentially dangerous as it seems that they have to be either in a carrier or on a lead and wearing a muzzle.
Your petitioners therefore request for Council to defer the off-leash trials until significant dog issues have been addressed effectively.
Council response
Thank you for your petition requesting Council defer dog off-leash area trials on beaches and foreshores until significant dog issues have been addressed.
The Foreshore Dog Off-leash Area Project (the project) is a joint project between Council, the Queensland Government’s Department of Environment and Science (DES) and The University of Queensland (UQ). The trial dog off-leash areas (trial areas) involved in the project were selected using comprehensive UQ research data and in accordance with the draft DES Marine Management Guideline (the draft guideline) for local government dog off-leash areas in Queensland marine parks. The 12-month trial period for the project commenced in October 2019 and was implemented as the Queensland pilot project for the draft guideline.
A key objective of the project was improving shorebird protection within Brisbane and Moreton Bay. UQ research showed that the trial areas feature low shorebird habitat values, but a high demand for dog off-leash use.
The regulatory framework within Brisbane’s foreshore areas is complex and Queensland Government support is required for any significant changes in use and activities on foreshore areas. Opportunities to establish foreshore dog off-leash areas in Brisbane have been investigated in the past, including as part of Council’s Sharing Shorelines project. While previous foreshore off leash area proposals did not proceed, they have contributed to the current project by demonstrating ongoing community interest and demand.
Council installed updated signage at each of the trial areas. The signs designated the boundaries of the trial areas and were considerably larger and brighter than existing signage. The updated signage contains a clear map of the trial areas and messaging about appropriate behaviour when visiting these spaces.
As with all dog off-leash areas, Council aims to encourage effective dog management and safety through community education and compliance. Council officers respond to safety issues and speak with people about effective dog management. As part of the trial, Council engaged a dog behaviouralist to provide dog behaviour advice. A video about appropriate use of the trial areas was published on Council’s website.
Council officers regularly patrolled the trial areas. People that allowed their dogs off-leash outside of designated areas or did not comply with Council’s Animals Local Law 2017 could be issued Penalty Infringement Notices.
Council implemented a variety of mechanisms to manage and address dog behaviour within the trial areas, including community education. Council responded to reports of dog attacks and aggressive dogs 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Reports of dog attacks occurring anywhere in the Brisbane Local Government Area are taken very seriously and thoroughly investigated.
The foreshore dog off-leash area trial recently came to an end. Council reviewed community feedback and shorebird monitoring data collected throughout the project. In addition, consideration was given to the Nudgee Beach Environmental Education Centre which engages learners from Prep to Year 12, along with the availability of the existing alternative dog off-leash facilities. As a result of the project, the foreshore dog off-leash areas at Sandgate and Manly will become permanent. Nudgee Beach will return to being a dog on-leash area.
Council notes your comments regarding the issue of dogs being allowed to travel on CityCats. You may be aware that Council operates CityCat and ferry services under an arrangement with TransLink, which is a division of the Queensland Government’s Department of Transport and Main Roads. TransLink is responsible for setting all conditions of travel, including policies regarding travelling with animals.
Designated companion and support animals, such as guide dogs, are permitted and have travelled for many years on public transport services in Queensland, including Council’s CityCat and ferry services. In late 2019, TransLink conducted a public survey on whether to allow pet dogs to travel on some public transport services and reported that more than 85% of respondents were supportive of the idea. Given this demonstration of public support, TransLink asked Council and Council’s contracted ferry operator, Transdev Brisbane Ferries Pty Ltd, to participate in a three month ‘pet dogs on ferries trial’, which commenced on 9 December 2019 and concluded on 31 May 2020.
Following the success of the trial, since 1 June 2020, pet dogs are permanently allowed on ferries under certain conditions, including wearing a muzzle or travelling in an enclosed carrier. In addition, dogs that have been identified as dangerous dogs in accordance with the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 are not permitted on CityCat or ferry services at any time.
Thank you for raising this matter.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...