Skip to main content

Activists' right to free speech and peaceful assembly

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 881
Closed: 14 Mar 2019
Principal petitioner: Leah Coutts
ePetition number: 657

The petition

Residents and ratepayers wish draw to the attention of the Honourable Lord Mayor Graham Quirk the excessive restrictions being placed by Council on activists exercising their right to free speech and lawful assembly. Specifically, animal activists participating in the Cube of Truth demonstrations in Reddacliff Place are being overly burdened by restrictions made under the Public Land and Council Assets Local Law 2014. Activists are told that failing to abide by Council’s restrictions will result in infringements and enforcement. However, Council’s restrictions are extreme and include banning speaking to members of the public or freely displaying non-commercialised educational material on screens. These restrictions are so extreme that compliance would effectively render the demonstration ineffective, making them a gag on free speech. When our Federal and State Governments have enshrined the right to gather and disseminate political communication, Council has an obligation to respect peaceful grassroots activity.

In placing any restrictions on content, Council needs to explain why images of standard Australian agricultural practices are not suitable for viewing on public land. We request written correspondence outlining how Council will respect residents’ civil liberties and explain how the restrictions were ever justified when the images displayed portray nothing but lawful agricultural activities.

Council response

Council notes your concerns about activists’ rights to free speech and peaceful assembly being overly burdened by restrictions made under the Public Land and Council Assets Local Law 2014 (PLACA), specifically, animal activists participating in the Cube of Truth demonstrations in Reddacliff Place. Under Queensland Government legislation enacted in 2010, the Queen Street Mall was extended to legally incorporate Reddacliff Place.

Reddacliff Place is an intensively-used commercial and recreational space and a busy pedestrian thoroughfare. The use of electronic display screens which broadcast graphic and distressing material, including images of animal cruelty and disfigurement, blood and the inhumane slaughter of animals, is deemed inappropriate for the location. The display of this graphic material unreasonably exposes members of the public to gratuitous interference with their freedom to go about their business, unimpeded and undistracted by the display of distressing content and the unsolicited tendering by strangers of literature of a distressing nature.

The effect of this activity at the proposed site in the Queen Street Mall will not optimise the benefit to be derived by the public from that public land and is likely to compromise, rather than safeguard, the safety and amenity of people using the area.

Council recognises that a person has the right to assemble peacefully with others in a public place under the Queensland Government’s Peaceful Assembly Act 1992 (PAA). However, the PAA specifically permits Council to regulate pedestrian malls. Council is not restricting the right to assemble in Reddacliff Place. The restrictions sought to be imposed relate to the conduct of the peaceful assembly, in particular that the images displayed and material handed out are not considered appropriate for the location.

Council acknowledges that a notice and the associated permission is restricted to the assembly being a static assembly, with no sound amplification, within the designated zone.

Peaceful assemblies in the Queen Street Mall are monitored by Council officers and CitySafe CCTV cameras to ensure that they comply with the conditions of the notification under the PAA and the regulations stated in the PAA. Council officers may take enforcement action under PLACA if any breaches of the conditions of consent or of PLACA are observed. Additionally, Queensland Police Service (QPS) officers may take appropriate action if there are any identified issues which may impact on the rights and freedoms of persons in a public place, or if they are requested to assist Council officers undertaking enforcement action.

For further information regarding the PAA, you may wish to contact the Queensland Government on (07) 3237 466 or via email at legislation.queries@oqpc.qld.gov.au .

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...