Reject highrise development proposal for 1032 apartments at 25 Donkin St, West End
The petition
Residents are concerned about the scale, density and suboptimal design outcomes of DA A005082417 and other associated development applications for the multi-stage highrise project at 25 Donkin St, West End. In particular, we are concerned that the current proposal for stage 1:
- will cause excessive traffic congestion associated with the 155 parking spaces
- is too close to the river and neighbouring public park
- is not sufficiently set back from property boundaries
- is excessively bulky
- does not comply with Council's 'Buildings that Breathe' guidelines in that apartments will be heavily reliant on air-conditioning
- has excessive site coverage
- does not have enough deep planting on site
- will unnecessarily remove established trees (both on site and on adjoining Council land)
- exceeds the acceptable outcome height limit for this site
- does not include any public housing or community housing and is therefore contrary to the public interest
- has a very high density that is not supported by sufficient local infrastructure or services.
We request that Council reject this development application in its current form, and insist on changes that:
- significantly reduce the number of apartments and carparks
- reduce site coverage and increase boundary setbacks, particularly to the public park
- reduce the height so that it matches the height of other neighbouring buildings
- includes at least 20% deep planting
- does not remove established trees from around the site
- includes 10% of dwellings as community housing or public housing.
We further request that Council requires the developer to facilitate a genuinely democratic community masterplanning process to design subsequent stages of the development in a manner that meets the needs of the broader community. We request that all development applications for this site be treated as impact assessable given that the developer is not complying with the acceptable height outcomes for the site.
Council response
On 26 June 2015, Council approved a development application for a multiple dwelling and food and drink outlet (application references A004016468, A004021212 and A004021234). The proposal included 988 units, together with 250 m 2 of food and drink outlets and 1,221 m 2 of office space, and outlined delivery of seven buildings over seven development stages.
The subject site is located within the High density residential zone of Brisbane City Plan 2014 (City Plan) and is within the Hocking Street sub-precinct of the Buchanan and Davies Park precinct within the South Brisbane riverside neighbourhood plan. The site is surrounded by residential land uses of up to 12 storeys and commercial development along Montague Road, West End.
A request to change a development approval under Section 369 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 was lodged with Council on 26 April 2017, and was approved on three stages of development, with Stage 1 comprising Building 1a, which contains 136 units and 250 m² food and drink outlets.
The petition refers to a development application for a minor change to an existing development approval that was made on 5 December 2018 and granted on 11 February 2019 (application reference A005082417). This application sought to amend the existing approved proposal with respect to Building 1a in line with the provisions of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act).
The application was code assessable per City Plan, and according to the provisions of the Act. Submissions received by Council were fully considered during the assessment process, but submitters did not have appeal rights within the Planning and Environment Court.
It is also noted that Council has no legislative means to either rescind an approval once granted or undertake representations to the applicant requesting amendments to their approved proposal.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...