Accept the Change.org petition regarding 160 Macquarie St, St Lucia submitted on 04/12/2018
The petition
On Tuesday, 4 December, 2018, Councillor Jonathan Sri submitted a petition to a full meeting of Brisbane City Council containing the names of almost 1200 residents who are concerned about highrise development proposals for 160 Macquarie St, St Lucia. BCC administration is suggesting that this Change.org petition is not a valid petition, even though the Change.org website has robust mechanisms to verify signatures and guard against the addition of false or duplicate names. The BCC's rules requiring that epetitions must include both a residential address and email address are not well-publicised or widely understood among residents. The BCC's own epetitions website is difficult to use, does not work on some devices, and requires multiple verification steps that discourage public participation. The original petition was clearly addressed to 'Brisbane Lord Mayor Graham Quirk' and substantially complied with BCC's petition policy. It included the full names and suburbs of petitioner, and residents were required to provide an email address to the website when filling out the petition. A large number of residents who feel ignored by council have sought to have their voices heard by signing an online petition. For BCC to refuse to consider this petition and to look into the very serious concerns about proposed development at 160 Macquarie St, St Lucia on a technicality would be undemocratic and would deny residents a voice.
Your petitioners therefore request that council consider the residents' petition submitted on their behalf by Councillor Sri on 4 December, 2018, objecting to the development application for 160 Macquarie St, St Lucia. We request that council reject the current development application for 160 Macquarie Street, St Lucia on the basis that it does not comply with the relevant provisions of the Brisbane City Plan including the Strategic Intent and 5 key themes in Part 3 of the plan.
Council response
Council’s AP107 Petitions to Council Procedure (the Procedure) requires that petitions include a minimum of three signatories, with their names and residential addresses (e.g. house number, street name, suburb, etc.). For ePetitions, email addresses are also required to be provided. These petition conditions are also outlined on Council’s website at www.brisbane.qld.gov.au. Council’s Procedure is similar to that used by the Australian and Queensland Parliaments. Without this information, Council does not have the means to verify petitioners’ details and their support for the petition, or to provide advice regarding the outcome of the petition.
Change.org requires that petitioners provide their name, email address and general geographic location (city, country and postcode), with only the details regarding each petitioner’s name, city and the date they signed the petition provided to the agency the petition is addressed to. Therefore Change.org petitions generally do not meet the requirements of the Procedure as Council does not receive sufficient details of a minimum of three petitioners’ full residential address and email address.
Council accepts paper petitions and provides an ePetitions system on its website. When an ePetition is signed through Council’s website, in addition to providing their name and residential address, a petitioner is required to verify their support for it by clicking on a link which is sent to their nominated email address. Verified email addresses also allow Council to contact all petitioners to provide advice regarding the outcome of the petition.
Council is unaware of the ePetitions system’s inability to function on some devices and would welcome feedback in relation to this in order to address this matter.
In respect of the development at 160 Macquarie Street, St Lucia, a development approval was granted on 27 September 2016 for a Multiple dwelling (26 units) within a 15-storey building and preliminary approval was granted for building works (application reference A004415389). Council received 17 public submissions.
On 20 August 2018, an application (application reference A005007317) was lodged with Council for a minor change to the development approval under section 81 of the Planning Act 2016 (the Act). The applications were assessed by Council’s Development Services, City Planning and Sustainability, against the requirements of Brisbane City Plan 2014 and in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Council received 34 public submissions.
The approved changes included the reduction of the approved building height by approximately 12.5 metres (number of storeys maintained at 15 storeys), increase in the number of units from 26 to 34, changes to balconies, additional visitor and bicycle parking spaces, and changes to communal recreation areas. All issues raised by submitters were taken into consideration during the assessments.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...