Request to remove a large non-native tree from a footpath at McIlwraith Avenue due to safety concerns
The petition
Residents draw to the attention of the Lord Mayor and Council risks to life or property and nuisance issues of having a large non-native tree growing on a footpath in close proximity to residential buildings. The tree we are referring to is a mature leopard tree located on a footpath outside properties on McIlwraith Avenue, Norman Park. The tree is approximately 15-20 metres tall and poses a great risk to public safety. The main concerns are:
1. Size of the tree and proximity to residential properties. In the event of a tree uprooting during a storm it would destroy buildings nearby.
2. The tree is growing close to a power lines pole and we believe does not comply with Energex Safe Tree guidelines which clearly state to apply 45 degree rule when planting trees i.e. a distance from the power line should be at least equal to the expected mature height of the plant. Furthermore clearance zone around power lines should be maintained according to the Electrical Safety Act (2002).
3. Damage to property - roots of the tree caused significant damage to private properties and infrastructure i.e. driveways, public footpath and a road surface near the tree. The particular species we are referring to is commonly known for having strong and invasive roots and its roots have tendency to spread beneath concrete, into pipes and sewage systems.
4. Slip hazards and restricting view and traffic signage visibility. The tree is located within a bus zone with a heavy pedestrian traffic during peak hours, especially morning. Fallen seed pods presents significant trip hazard to pedestrians and also restricts visibility when accessing driveways.
5. Nuisance and risks of flooding. The tree drops leaves, flowers and hard, black seed pods all year round with significant increase in autumn. Debris from the tree enters into gutters, and gathers around storm water drains blocking access which in the event of a heavy rain then results in flooding of a driveway. Some of the properties are within storm water overland flow path and again increase the risk of flooding to properties.
After doing some investigation into this matter we discovered most councils in South East Queensland no longer plant leopard trees on footpaths due to public safety and nuisance issues. Furthermore, as of 2013 Brisbane City Council made a promise to relax Tree and Vegetation Protection Laws and place more emphasis on risks to life or property and nuisance issues.
Your petitioners therefore request Council to urgently prioritize the investigation and schedule a removal of the aforementioned tree from a footpath so that residents' and general public's safety is not compromised.
Council response
Thank you for your petition requesting that Council remove a large non-native tree growing on the footpath in close proximity to properties in McIlwraith Avenue, Norman Park.
Council has completed an onsite investigation and considered your request.
Council values the trees in our city as they contribute significantly to the environment both ecologically and aesthetically. These values are supported by Council’s tree policy which ensures the preservation of Council trees, therefore tree removal is considered an important issue.
Council does not support the removal of the tree in McIlwraith Avenue, Norman Park, as the tree does not meet Council’s tree removal criteria. The tree was found to be in good health and form.
Trees are not removed based on seed and leaf drop, as this is a natural process. As the leaf drop and seed cycle is seasonal, it is accepted at certain times it may be more prolific than others. The management of blocked gutters and stormwater drains is the responsibility of the homeowner and should be managed through general property maintenance.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...