Skip to main content

Reopen Southside Pony Club Footbridge

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 402
Closed: 3 Sept 2018
Principal petitioner: Kara Cook
ePetition number: 576

The petition

Residents draw to the attention of the Lord Mayor that the footbridge connecting the Southside Pony Club to Beelarong Street Morningside was closed by Council without notice in May 2017. This has caused danger and inconvenience both to the Southside Pony Club membership and residents of the local area who have lost a vital connection between Barwon Street and Beelarong Street.

Your petitioners therefore request that the footbridge be urgently repaired and reopened so that this vital connection can be reinstated.

Council response

The bridge is located in the Brisbane suburb of Morningside and crosses Perrin Creek. The bridge connects several open plots of land which have been used historically for the agistment of horses. The bridge, which has no direct public access or connections, was privately constructed and certified in 2001 by the owners to facilitate safe access across Perrin Creek. It is noted that the area at this time underwent significant development and lot reconfiguration. The Council land at 112 Beelarong Street is leased to the SPC.

Questions surrounding the bridge’s ownership were raised in March 2017 following negotiations to lease the land at 112 Beelarong Street to the SPC. During these discussions, it was identified that the bridge was not recorded as being a Council asset. A review of Council records does not indicate that the bridge was ever transferred to Council’s ownership. In order for Council to assume maintenance and ownership of the bridge, a level 2 condition assessment was undertaken in May 2017. This assessment identified significant damage to the timber piles supporting the bridge ranging from 50% to 90% timber loss. The deck boards were also identified as being in poor condition.

Your comments about not being advised of the bridge’s closure have been noted. As a result of the level 2 assessment, the bridge was not considered safe for public use and was subsequently closed in May 2017 to protect public safety. SPC was notified at this time not to use the bridge for these reasons.

A copy of this assessment report undertaken in May 2017 has since been provided to the SPC.

Following a request from the Lord Mayor in August 2018 into the options for repair of the bridge or re-opening of the bridge with load restrictions, a report was commissioned. A level 3 engineering investigation report was subsequently commissioned and provided to Council in October 2018, confirming that the structural integrity of this bridge is severely compromised and rated as unsafe to use and should remain closed until such time as the known defects are rectified.

There are no paths connecting this bridge to any footpath or bikeway link coming from either Barwon Street or Beelarong Street. The only access to this bridge is through the SPC, which is private property. The Beelarong Street end is fenced with a locked gate installed. As such, the bridge is solely used by SPC members and there is no substantial active transport value to provide a link via this bridge.

Council has considered a number of options in relation to the future of the bridge which include: - removing the bridge at an estimated cost of $100,000 - removing and replacing the bridge with a new concrete structure at an estimated cost of $2 million - repairing the current bridge to an acceptable standard at an estimated cost of $360,000 - building an alternative non-concrete structure such as a Fibre Reinforced Polymer (FRP) bridge.

An alternative FRP bridge is not considered appropriate in this location as the area has a very high flood likelihood and any structure which Council installs must not increase the flood risk to upstream areas. FRP bridges typically have a greater overall deck depth which causes increased flood levels upstream, which are not desirable in flood prone areas. In addition, FRP is a relatively new material which has no current Australian Standard and no supplier can guarantee the bridge could meet the required 100-year design life requirement for bridges in urban environments.

For these reasons, repairing the bridge is Council’s preferred solution. In response to the recent level 3 engineering report undertaken in October 2018, the repair works required to reopen the bridge have been identified. Accordingly, Council proposes to list these repair works for funding in its 2019-20 budget. Should funding be allocated, it is anticipated that the works will be completed before the end of the 2019-20 financial year, weather permitting.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...