Skip to main content

Australian International Islamic College application to override the planning scheme.

View on the council website (opens in a new tab)
Status: CLOSED, finished
Signatures: 2,107
Closed: 30 June 2017
Principal petitioner: Elizabeth Thompson
ePetition number: 439

The petition

DEVELOPMENT ALERT: Urban Planning Application number A004061627. The Proposal : Real Property Signs have proposed preliminary approval for a material change of use Under section 242 to override the planning scheme for community facilities – Education Purposes (child care and recreation, office, shop, short term accommodation) multiple dwelling and aged care accommodation. Page 5 of the Economic Need Assessment: Australian International Islamic College describes this as — 2.2: Proposed Development The Proposed development is a master planned, mixed-use precinct which would ultimately include 3,000 m2 of retail, commercial and medical space over two levels; an aged care facility; 120 residential apartments; a Mosque; additional classrooms and a child care centre to support an ultimate capacity of more than 2,000 students. The development would have an important cultural orientation towards Mecca and as illustrated in FIGURE 2.2 creates a public pedestrian boulevard linking through the major uses proposed in creating a significant node and cultural Middle Eastern and South East Asian hub.

We object to the building of this development for the following reasons:

1) The area being 11.5 hectares (some of which is in bushland and under flood covenant) is too small for the type of development that is being proposed and leads to concerns for the safety of 2,000 students and the residents of 120 apartments being proposed. The height of the multiple dwellings (four blocks of five-storey apartments) is not in keeping with surrounding developments which consist of one and two-storey homes and units. There is not the need in the suburb for the type of high density apartment living that requires building upward in order to place more development on a smaller piece of land.

2) It is noted that the proposed development will include a mosque — the concern is that the noise level and timing of Calls to Prayer will infringe on neighbourhood quality of life. Calls to prayers are traditionally hailed over a loud speaker system from the top of a mosque five times a day, seven days a week. It is understood that the first Call to Prayer is pre-dawn with the last being at night. Events in the past (Ramadan) and previous lunch time calls to prayer that used to occur within the college were done using a loud hailer system — the noise level was protested against by residents in the neighbouring park. The mosque is to be situated close to the boundary of the caravan/residential home park and will be two levels high, we understand. The noise level and the timing of Calls to Prayer is not acceptable within a residential neighbourhood.

3) The development will impact detrimentally on the privacy and well being of neighbouring developments. We note that on page 4 of the Need Assessment : Australian International Islamic College — 2.1: The Subject site nearby uses include a caravan park. The said 'caravan park' (256 sites in total) whose land abuts the proposed site has over three quarters of the land (approximately 123 residential sites) allocated to an 'over 50s' owner occupied residential home park. If it were solely a 'caravan park' certainly when the residents find the noise and congestion intolerable they can remove themselves elsewhere. This is a residential home park, where the owners have bought their homes and pay Brisbane City Council rates. The residents purchased their homes to enjoy the peace and quiet that surrounds them on this property. Most residents are in their late 60s, 70s and 80s and many have been residents in the park for over 25 years. These residents will have no way of being able to remove themselves either financially or physically to alternative suitable surroundings.

4) The increase in vehicles from the development will increase congestion and hazard on Blunder Road. It is too close to the major intersection of Inala Avenue and Blunder Road. At the present time when college starts and finishes it is hazardous turning into Durack Gardens driveway with vehicles emerging from the driveway of the college into the same lane. The distance is too short to alert vehicles following when turning indicators on after passing the college driveway. Vehicles coming through the intersection must use the centre lane and are unable to get into the lane in time to turn into Durack Gardens driveway due to cars exiting from the college. The proposed development will worsen this situation.

5) Onsite parking will be inadequate for the full development. Provision on the proposed plan is for 150 parking spaces for stage one of the development. This is expected to cater for the ground floor and first floor centre, half space for each unit in the short-term accommodation and 0.5 space per staff. That does not allow for the mosque attendees (it has been stated that this development is expected to be the Brisbane Islamic hub) the car parking requirement will definitely exceed availability. This also does not allow for parking for the 150 apartments or the vehicles collecting 2,000 proposed college students. There is not enough room within the site to cater for the number of car park spaces that will be required for the ultimate development. Concern is also felt that planning applications will then be made to Council to override existing covenants on surrounding land.

6) On 18 April 2016, Bartley Burns stated in their response to Council's Information Request 22 April 2015 “It should be noted at this stage, that while the proposal will be open and accessible to the general public, it is focussed for the Islamic community of Brisbane. While this community is supported by a number of scattered services across the region, they have no central hub such as that proposed”. We feel that the apparent exclusivity of the proposed development to a religious group will not offer any benefit to the community it is situated in as a whole and is inconsistent with the multicultural community that already exists in the suburb.

7) There are excellent services available within and close to the local community that cater for a diverse range of cultural and religious requirements. Inala shopping centre is five minutes away from the proposed development offering services for all cultures and religions — Medina Quality Meats in Inala Plaza and Oxley Halal Meats at 72 Cook Street Oxley are very conveniently situated for the supply of Halal meats. Inala, Richlands, Oxley and Forest Lake all have family medical practices that include at least one woman doctor in them. The Islamic Society of Darra, an eight-minute drive away at 219 Douglas Street has a mosque that is open for five daily prayers. The society is ideally situated in a semi rural/industrial area where the noise issue is not as critical to a surrounding residential population.

Your petitioners therefore request that council decline Urban Planning Application number A004061627.

Comments · 0

Loading...

Loading comments...