Business Council of Australia—Answer to a question on notice asked by Senator McDonald at a committee hearing in Canberra on 30 October 2026
Response
Senate Economics Legislation Committee Business Council of Australia Questions on Notice Q: That's been a very helpful discussion. I have a couple more questions I might put to you on notice, particularly around clauses 26 and 27 and some of the contract law terminology. It's been put to me that the legislation is not reflective of good commercial contract law. It doesn't refer to 'force majeure'; it's refers to 'breach'. I think we've got some problems there, if we're serious about trying to provide better clarity around contracts, that we need to tidy up. I'll put those on notice and, if you've got some good advice—no doubt you've got good contract lawyers in your world—that would probably be very helpful. A: The BCA considers that clauses 26 and 27 should be clarified to ensure a licence holder is not denied an adjustment solely because a force majeure, change in law or similar provision excuses non- performance caused by the domestic supply obligation. For an existing export contract, the Minister may grant a DSO adjustment under clause 26(1)(a) only if satisfied that the licence holder would likely breach a contract term without the adjustment (clause 27(1)(a)). Commercial contracts may contain force majeure, change in law or similar provisions that suspend or excuse delivery obligations in specified circumstances. If such a provision applies, missed deliveries may not amount to a breach. A licence holder could therefore be ineligible for an adjustment on that basis even where meeting the domestic supply obligation would prevent it from making export deliveries it had already agreed to make. The BCA recommends clarifying that a licence holder can still qualify for a DSO adjustment even if its contract excuses missed deliveries caused by the domestic supply obligation. This clarification should preserve the parties’ contractual rights and remain subject to an assessment of reasonably available alternatives. That assessment should expressly consider the practical and commercial feasibility of alternative supply, including availability, cost, timing, transport and contractual restrictions. Separately, regardless of any export contract terms, the Government should also clarify whether the Bill’s existing flexibility provisions or proposed rules provide relief when events beyond a licence holder’s reasonable control prevent compliance, including relief from carrying forward shortfalls or incurring penalties.
Comments · 0
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...